Arguments were heard on Thursday in a lawsuit brought by school districts looking to remove new provisions to over $300 million in state safety and mental health grant funds.

In order to receive grant funds, districts that opt-in must, “agree to be subject to a comprehensive investigation, must affirmatively agree to waive any privilege that may otherwise protect information from disclosure in the event of a mass casualty event, and must agree to comply with a comprehensive investigation.”

Districts such as the Wayne Regional Service Agency, the Oakland, Macomb and Monroe intermediate school districts, as well as individual schools districts, filed suit to have the privilege provisions removed. The state, the Michigan Department of Education and state school superintendent were named as defendants.

“This was rushed legislation and rushed legislation often results in bad legislation,” Miller Canfield attorney Scott Eldridge, arguing on behalf of the districts, said in court. “It was so eye-poppingly bad language that we had to turn plaintiffs away from being involved in this case.”

“When you couple the ‘any privilege’ language with the ‘mass casualty event’ language, you have the constitutional problem that is in front of you,” Eldridge told Judge Sima Patel.

He said the privilege provision was a violation of constitutional due process because the language is too vague or “void for vagueness”.

“Void of vagueness” refers to the legal principle which invalidates laws that are so unclear that ordinary people can’t understand what conduct is prohibited or allow for enforcement which violates due process under the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments.

“It does not give enough direction to school administrators who are responsible for invoking privileges in various contexts throughout their day and throughout their job administering and overseeing schools,” said Eldridge.

Adam de Bear, assistant attorney general at the Michigan Department of Attorney General office arguing on behalf of the state, said employees and administrators in districts that did sign the off on the waiver have the right to invoke their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination in an investigation and can hire their own attorneys and invoke attorney-client privilege in any civil matters.

“Just because the statute or the waiver is unpopular amongst the schools to which it will be enforced, doesn’t mean it’s unconstitutional,” de Bear said.

He added that school districts as individual entities do not have constitutional protections because they are governmental agencies and public bodies.

The new provisions are part of the State School Aid Act and any violation of any part of the act is a misdemeanor criminal offense, which means invoking privilege after accepting the funds could lead to criminal charges.

Eldridge went on to say that waiving privilege extends not just to an investigation, but to civil litigation, criminal investigations, Freedom of Information Act requests and Open Meetings Act guidelines.

“Now if a mass casualty event has occurred and now we have waived any privilege, if there is civil litigation related to the mass casualty event, which invariably happens, now your attorney-client privilege is blown up, you cannot invoke it under this waiver,” he explained.

Districts around Oakland County have voted to opt-in for their share of grant funding, which Huron Valley Superintendent Paul Salah estimated to be $140 per student enrolled in each district.

Rochester schools voted to accept an estimated $2.1 million, Farmington $1.2 million and South Lyon $1 million.

Eldridge summed up what the overall problem is with the new provisions.

“What creates the unconstitutional condition is the state is not allowed to dangle government benefits in front of folks in exchange for the relinquishment of constitutional protections,” said Eldridge. “People are being asked to either take this money and waive privileges or miss out on hundreds of thousands of dollars.”

Toni Harris, representing the Michigan Department of Education (MDE), said the decision of the court and possible appeals afterward could be a major issue for the department.

“If they (school districts) get an unfavorable ruling in this court and then get an unfavorable result in the Court of Appeals they still have the opportunity to get before the (state) Supreme Court,’ said Harris. “These are not going to be done in a matter of months and MDE could be faced with figuring out two fiscal years later that schools who opted-in this year are now opting out in, let’s say, June 2027, the MDE has to track those funds and recoup those funds, which from a government perspective is not a simple task.”

School districts have until Dec. 30 to opt-out and a ruling is expected next week.