Michael was 16 when she served as the driver on April 23, 2025<\/a>, for her boyfriend, Byron Rangel. He was the gunman who pulled the trigger at arm\u2019s length from the back of the head of Caleb Quick, 18, according to prosecutors.<\/p>\n Along with hearing from 15 witnesses, Gaab said she had read through reports from probation and others, multiple petitions and the briefs of final arguments from the defense and prosecuting attorneys. Both sides also gave final remarks in the courtroom on Friday.<\/p>\n In recent years, there has been an evolving perspective<\/a> in California of how the courts treat young people who commit crimes, and the burden of proof to transfer a young offender to an adult court falls on prosecutors.<\/p>\n \u201cThe evidence must be so clear as to leave no doubt,\u201d Gaab said, quoting from case law.<\/p>\n There are several points weighed in such cases.<\/p>\n Was the minor 16 or older?How does the minor hold up to the five factors in a transfer hearing?Is the minor amenable to rehabilitation?<\/p>\n The first criterion was not disputed by either side. Michael was 17 years and 9 months old on Friday, and was 16 years and 8 months old on the day she\u2019s accused of being the getaway driver in the execution-style killing of Quick, Gaab noted.<\/p>\n The second criterion itself has five factors.<\/p>\n The degree of sophistication of the crime.Totality of the circumstances and seriousness of the crime.The likeliness of rehabilitation of the teen.Previous history of delinquency.Success of previous attempts at rehabilitation.<\/p>\n Gaab said she believed Michael showed a high level of sophistication in the crime, noting the teen had made an effort to find Quick on the night of the killing. The girl also provided an alibi for her boyfriend and made plans, like making sure to park the getaway car where it could leave the area faster.<\/p>\n \u201cThey showed a degree of sophistication planning to kill the victim at a place the victim was known to be,\u201d Gaab said.<\/p>\n Cellphone data appeared to show the teen couple\u2019s movements together through the time running up to the killing, she said. Rangel changed clothes before the shooting, and Gaab said the evidence showed Michael was with him when he did it.<\/p>\n Michael spoke to others at the McDonald\u2019s about an alleged sexual assault<\/a> by Caleb Quick on a friend of Michael\u2019s, the judge noted.<\/p>\n \u201cThis was not rash behavior,\u201d Gaab said. \u201cThe minor appeared to be avenging her friend.\u201d<\/p>\n After the shooting at McDonald\u2019s, Michael fled into the parking lot to get to the getaway car while others inside tried to stop her after hearing the gunfire, Gaab noted. Michael was seen on a home surveillance camera a short distance from the McDonald\u2019s picking up Rangel and honking to get his attention as he ran.<\/p>\n The teen also attempted to give her car away days after the killing, Gaab said, an attempt to conceal her guilt.<\/p>\n As for the gravity of the crime and totality of the circumstances, they clearly leaned toward a transfer to an adult hearing, Gaab said. She noted Quick was a teenager when he was killed execution style while the shooter was lying in wait.<\/p>\n \u201cThere is no question the facts of this offense are serious and the consequences are extreme,\u201d she said.<\/p>\n The other three factors in a transfer \u2014 likeliness of rehabilitation, previous delinquency and previous attempts at rehab \u2014 all weighed in Michael\u2019s favor.<\/p>\n The girl had no previous trouble with the law and had not been through previous attempts at rehabilitation. She has been in a juvenile facility for about a year, and had performed well, according to testimony. Gaab said those weighed in favor of denying transfer.<\/p>\n As for the third criterion \u2014 amenability to rehabilitation \u2014 Michael had performed well, Gaab said. Testimony showed the girl had cooperated in custody, finishing high school and becoming a tutor to aid others. She sought therapy and showed improved maturity.<\/p>\n Gaab said although the gravity and sophistication of the crime were factors in the case, she was required to deny the transfer. State laws requires prosecutors to prove Michael could not be rehabilitated.<\/p>\n \u201cAll of the evidence presented, including by the peoples\u2019 expert, has been to the contrary,\u201d Gaab said.<\/p>\n Michael was scheduled to return to juvenile court on June 5. The other teen accused in the killing, Rangel, could see his own transfer hearing next month.<\/p>\n Stephen Quick, the father of Caleb Quick, wears a button while he speaks to media outside the Fresno County Courthouse on Friday, May 15, 2026, after a judge decided one of the two teens accused of killing his son will remain in the juvenile justice system. THADDEUS MILLER tmiller@fresnobee.com
![\"Caleb](\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/05\/1779136689_462_image.png\" "\\"image.png\\"")
Caleb Quick, 18, was killed in April at a McDonald\u2019s parking lot in Clovis, California. CALEB QUICK GOFUNDME ![\"Fresno](\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/05\/1779136690_461_FRS_FRESNOCOUNTYCOURTHOUSESIGN.JPG\" "\\"FRS_FRESNOCOUNTYCOURTHOUSESIGN.JPG\\"")
Fresno County Superior Courthouse, 1100 Van Ness Ave, Fresno on March 2, 2021. JOHN WALKER The Fresno Bee
\n Related Stories from Fresno Bee<\/p>\n