TAMPA, Fla. — It took two decades to find the answers, but the family of Tammy Fickey finally knows who killed her. However, the man responsible will never stand before a judge.
The Hillsborough County Sheriff’s Office announced this week that the 2005 murder of Fickey, 31, is officially closed. Homicide detectives determined that Arthur “Heavy” Debose was the killer, but time ran out before the legal system could catch up. Debose died of natural causes in June 2024, just as authorities were preparing to file charges.
The investigation began on the evening of March 12, 2005. Around 7:30 p.m., deputies were called to an area behind 13613 21st Street North, where they found Fickey’s body. Her death was quickly ruled a homicide.
READ: Without A Trace: Florida College Student, Tiffany Louise Sessions, Still Missing 36 Years Later
While investigators determined the crime had taken place inside a nearby apartment and even identified a person of interest early on, the physical evidence at the time wasn’t strong enough to support an arrest. The case eventually went cold.
Files on the murder sat dormant until November 2022, when the Cold Case Unit launched a fresh review. Detectives ordered new forensic testing on old evidence and tracked down witnesses—both old and new—to see if their stories had changed. The renewed push led them back to a familiar name: Arthur Debose.
By December 2022, Debose was already sitting in a cell at the RMC Correctional Facility on unrelated drug charges. When detectives went to interview him, authorities say he slipped up. According to the Sheriff’s Office, Debose gave conflicting statements and, crucially, revealed specific details about the crime scene that investigators determined only the killer would know.
READ: Without A Trace: Three Decades Later, Police In Florida Still Searching For Shanythia Peterson
Detectives spent the next year and a half solidifying the case, concluding that Debose, 54, was responsible for Fickey’s death. But before the state could formally charge him, he died in custody on June 17, 2024.
Sheriff Chad Chronister acknowledged the bittersweet nature of the resolution.
“For twenty years, the name Tammy Fickey never left the minds of our investigators, because time does not diminish our responsibility to the victims we serve,” Chronister said. “While the suspect’s death prevents the accountability we pursue in every case, I am incredibly proud of the relentless work of our Cold Case Unit, whose dedication ensured the truth was uncovered and Tammy’s family was not forgotten.”
Fickey’s next of kin have been notified that the investigation is now closed due to the death of the offender.
Please make a small donation to the Tampa Free Press to help sustain independent journalism. Your contribution enables us to continue delivering high-quality, local, and national news coverage.
Sign up: Subscribe to our free newsletter for a curated selection of top stories delivered straight to your inbox.