There are good things and bad things about being a foodie in a place like Jacksonville. On the positive side, you can find just about any cuisine you desire in a city of this size. But the city is so geographically large that you might have to drive an hour to find what you’re looking for.
So we’re trying to make it a little easier on you by highlighting a half-dozen “hidden gems” of the Northeast Florida dining scene. They’re the kind of place where the regulars know the menu by heart, and they’ve been around long enough to know what they’re doing, but for one reason or another, they don’t get a lot of publicity.
We dug through Times-Union archives and online reviews to find an Iraqi restaurant with a rock and roll attitude, an old favorite that’s opened a new location, a Northside place that closes just after lunchtime, a place known for great fish sandwiches and dessert, an old-school seafood joint and a Five Points pizza spot that’s catching on quickly.
Be the first to know: Sign up for Dining Notes, our free weekly newsletter for the latest restaurant news in Jacksonville
Fast Eddy’s Quick Mideast
Fast Eddy’s Quick Mideast, 10915 Baymeadows Road, Suite 105
10915-#105 Baymeadows Road, (904) 619-9173, fasteddysquickmideast.com
Fast Eddy’s Quick Mideast is without a doubt Jacksonville’s finest rock ‘n’ roll Mideastern restaurant (not that there’s a lot of competition for that crown). It was opened in 2021 by two Iraqi-American brothers and specializes in Chaldean cuisine, a mix of Middle Eastern and Indian influences.
Rock posters, CDs and guitars cover the walls, and you can order a beer to go with your meal. The menu has Middle Eastern dishes such as Shijjar, Bamiyah and Fattoush (with a handy pronunciation guide), but also a Star Spangled Burger and Summer Time Chicken Salad.
The French Pantry
The French Pantry, 6301-1 Powers Ave.
6301-1 Powers Ave., (904) 454-8719, thefrenchpantry.com
People have been lining up for bruschettas, po’ boys and French dip sandwiches at the original location for years. French Pantry started out as a commercial bakery but added a restaurant when students from the nearby Wolfson High School started asking for sandwiches. It’s open Monday through Saturday, 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.
Now, diners can also enjoy the French Pantry in St. Augustine. 36 Granada, which opened in 2024, combines the French Pantry with the Little Miss Ha Vietnamese restaurant, Le Petite Kitchen and the Cache Cache speakeasy bar, all under one roof. French Pantry offers breakfast, lunch and dinner menus at the St. Augustine location.
New location: 36 Granada featuring French Pantry, new Vietnamese restaurant debuts in St. Augustine
Old Soul Donuts
Old Soul Donuts, 11230 New Berlin Road
11230 New Berlin Road, (904) 647-9112, facebook.com
Old Soul Donuts has the “hidden” part covered, located on New Berlin Road not far from the base of the Dames Point Bridge, but it’s rapidly losing its “hidden gem” status. In a reader poll of Jacksonville doughnut shops last March, Old Soul finished second. On the other hand, they don’t have a website and close every day just after lunch.
The menu is Texas-inspired. Doughnuts, of course, are on the menu, but the owners consider the apple fritter to be their signature offering, and visitors really love the kolaches, hand-held breakfast sandwiches stuffed with sausage, ham or cheese.
Jax Fish Fry
Jax Fish Fry, 170 Fountains Way, St. Johns
170 Fountains Way in St. Johns, (904) 217-8945, jaxfishfry.com
You’ll have to go to St. Johns for some of the Jacksonville area’s best Northern-style fried cod and lobster rolls after Jax Fish Fry lost the lease on its original Baymeadows location. Owners are reportedly looking for a new site, but for now, the St. Johns location is the place for made-to-order fried cod sandwiches, lobster rolls, shrimp baskets, crab cakes and clam rolls.
The original site opened in 2020, just before COVID shut down the entire restaurant industry. The fried cod sandwich, lightly dusted with a secret breading and served on a split-top bun, is a big favorite, but be sure to save room for the house-made desserts.
Junior’s Seafood
Junior’s Seafood, 9349 N. Main St.
9349 N. Main St., (904) 751-9180; 45061 SR 200 in Callahan, (904) 628-0755, juniorsseafoodrestaurant.com
Junior’s Seafood is the kind of place where they’ll give you a discount if you show the cashier your church bulletin, and it has a menu that would make Bubba Gump’s mouth water — Jumbo Shrimp-n-Grits, Bam-Bam Shrimp, Bayou Boiled Shrimp, Popcorn Shrimp, Big Cats Buffalo Shrimp…
Sure, you can get a chicken sandwich or a burger, but seafood is king at Junior’s and diners praise the large portions. The menu includes flounder, tilapia, whiting, catfish, salmon and mahi-mahi, plus Heckscher Drive Crab Cakes and, of course, gator tail. All signs of a 2022 fire that devastated the Main Street location are gone.
Rodrigo’s Craft Pizza
Rodrigo’s Craft Pizza, 1029 Park St.
1029 Park St., (904) 367-3112, rodrigoscraftpizza.com
Rodrigo’s Craft Pizza opened in Five Points late in 2023 and quickly became one of Jacksonville’s favorite pizza places. They do it by simultaneously making the city’s slowest and fastest pizzas.
The slow part is the dough, which ferments for a minimum of three days before it ever sees a sauce; the fast part is the cooking, which is done in a super-hot oven and takes about five minutes, tops. The 12-inch pies come in 10 varieties, and you can buy a ball of dough to take home and create your own pizza.
This article originally appeared on Florida Times-Union: Six hidden gem restaurants in Jacksonville you need to try