MONROE COUNTY, Fla. (CBS12) — Nine years after Hurricane Irma, advanced genetic genealogy helped investigators finally identify human remains found in a Big Pine Key debris pile, confirming they belonged to 77-year-old James Donald Schlake of Key Largo.
The Florida Department of Law Enforcement announced on Wednesday that it assisted in the identification, working with Othram Inc., a DNA laboratory that specializes in advanced DNA sequencing and genetic genealogy research. FDLE Forensic Services secured funding for the work through the State Forensic Investigative Genetic Genealogy Grant Fund on behalf of the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office and the Monroe County Medical Examiner.
“FDLE’s Key West Field Office and Forensic Services turned over every stone to identify Mr. Schlake,” FDLE Commissioner Mark Glass said. “Our statewide forensic resources and strong partnerships are critical to supporting Florida’s communities and law enforcement agencies. This collaboration helped bring longawaited answers to Mr. Schlake’s loved ones and to the Florida Keys community.”
Kristen Mittelman, Chief Development Officer for Othram, said the case shows how far technology has come. “People should know that it doesn’t matter how old a case is — if there is DNA, there is technology today that can bring answers to families. This is powerful technology, and cases like this can absolutely be solved.”
See also: Free college tuition available for Treasure Coast high school seniors at IRSC
Schlake’s remains were originally discovered on Sept. 14, 2017, during poststorm searchandrescue operations in Big Pine Key. The Monroe County Medical Examiner ruled the cause and manner of death as accidental drowning, but the advanced state of decomposition prevented identification.
Investigators attempted DNA analysis in December 2023 through FDLE’s crime laboratories, but no leads were found. In June 2025, a sample was sent to Othram for additional sequencing and genealogical research. By December 2025, potential genetic relatives had been identified, allowing investigators to confirm Schlake’s identity and notify his family.
FDLE said it remains committed to using emerging forensic tools and strong partnerships to support local agencies, bring closure to families and strengthen public safety statewide.