Jon-Eric Sullivan got the quarterback question on Thursday during his first press conference as the general manager of the Miami Dolphins.
The NFL team wasn’t supposed to be dealing with this issue after signing Tua Tagovailoa to a $212.4 million contract extension in 2024. But the former Alabama All-American got benched with three games remaining in the 2025 campaign, leaving a new general manager and a new coach to determine how to proceed at the position and how – or if – Tagovailoa figures in those plans.
Sullivan said he had “a lot of respect for Tua,” but deemed it too soon in the process to make a declaration of direction.
On Friday, new Dolphins coach Jeff Hafley got asked the quarterback question during an appearance on “The Rich Eisen Show.”
“That’s a fair question,” Hafley said. “And it’s one Jon-Eric, and I talked about throughout the meetings It’s one we talked about with everybody in the meetings. And there’ll be guys on this roster who compete and there’ll be guys that we’ll go out and get that will compete.
“I think it’s obviously early in this process. This is literally my first day full-time on the job. I couldn’t even tell you where I am in the building right now or how to get back to my office, so I think the quarterback plan is going to probably take a little time.”
FOR MORE OF AL.COM’S COVERAGE OF THE NFL, GO TO OUR NFL PAGE
Hafley said he thought Miami would have a competitive quarterback depth chart to decide the starter.
“I think there has to be, regardless of who’s here,” Hafley said. “I mean, I think that’s important at all positions. And you can tell me that’s coach talk and part of that is coach talk, so let’s be honest. But, yeah, I do see that there’s going to be competition at the quarterback position and at all levels.”
Hafley came to Miami after serving as the defensive coordinator for the Green Bay Packers. While giving no specifics about quarterback plans, Hafley did share what he hoped the Dolphins’ offense would look like in the 2026 season, although he has not hired an offensive coordinator yet.
“We got to be able to run the football,” Hafley said. “And it has to start up front. It has to get the quarterback under center. I like the play pass, the keepers, the boots and the screens, the different motions to create leverage, tying in the run in the pass game, trying to create that different levels between the second- and third-level stuff that I think is hard to defend from a defensive play-caller.
“And then it’s really going to come down to the pieces that we have and what can we do best? We’ve got some good pieces on offense, but I’m also a believer that you got to get a guy who can take the players that he has and adapt the offense, certainly within your philosophy, put those guys in position to have success.
“And if it’s a quarterback that can be under center – great. If it’s a quarterback that cannot, then we’ll have to get created and play in the gun more. But you got to establish the run game, and you got to have actions off of it. And you got to be great situationally.
“And then as a defensive guy, I want someone that’s going to hunt explosives because everything I do on every single situation on defense is to eliminate explosives. And I think on offense, that’s how you score points.”
The No. 5 pick in the 2020 NFL Draft, Tagoviloa became Miami’s starting quarterback during his rookie season and was a Pro Bowl selection in 2023.
But in 2025, Tagovailoa’s stats were down across the board – except for interceptions. With a career-high 15, Tagovailoa had the second-most in the NFL even though he didn’t play in the final three games.
Complicating the Dolphins’ decision is Tagovailoa’s contract situation.
If Tagovailoa is with the Dolphins two months from now, he’ll cost Miami $57 million. His contract includes a guarantee of $54 million for the 2026 season, and $3 million of his 2027 salary becomes guaranteed if Tagovailoa is on the team’s roster three days after the next free-agency period begins in March.
If the Dolphins release Tagovailoa before then, he will count $99.2 million against their 2026 salary cap – about one-third of the team’s total to spend and $42.8 million more than if he is on the team. Some NFL bookkeeping regulations could reduce the hit to $67.4 million in 2026, with the other $31.8 million in dead money kicked down the road to the 2027 salary cap if he’s designated as a June 1 release.