Although the Magic entered Tuesday’s game against the Thunder with an 8-2 record in games on the second night of a back-to-back, Orlando was facing a different type of challenge when it returned to Kia Center after falling at Atlanta the night prior.

Oklahoma City went into the game with the best record in the NBA, had won its past eight contests and already beaten Jamahl Mosley‘s squad by 36 points at home in early February.

Despite those factors, the Magic fought back-and-forth late with the top team in the league until Oklahoma City ultimately pulled away in the fourth quarter to capture a 113-108 victory during its lone trip of the regular season to Central Florida.

In the middle of a second consecutive league MVP-caliber season, Shai Gilgeous-Alexander posted a game-high 40 points, outdueling Orlando’s Paolo Banchero, who notched 32 in 36 minutes.

“No. 2, Shai Gilgeous,” Mosley said when asked what he felt was ultimately the reason Orlando fell short. “We talked about it before the game, what he’s capable of doing. He got himself going tonight. … He finds a way. He’s slippery getting to the rim.”

Oklahoma City (54-15) overcame 3-point shooting woes (it ended 31% from distance) by scoring 15 points off 12 Orlando turnovers and finishing with a 53-41 advantage on the glass to win its ninth in a row.

“They’re a great team and they showed that in the second half,” Banchero said about the Thunder.

After dropping their past two games, the Magic (38-30) head back on the road when they travel to Charlotte for a key Southeast Division matchup Thursday.

Banchero’s impact

The Magic forward hit his first jumpshot and his first 3-pointer to help post eight points in the opening quarter.

Adding five in the second frame, he didn’t slow down in the third by continuing to penetrate the paint, getting to the free throw line and finding his spots on the floor.

Scoring all of Orlando’s first eight points in the third quarter, he notched 26 points in his first 23 minutes of action by starting 3 for 5 from beyond the arc. With 10 rebounds, Tuesday’s game marked Banchero’s team-leading 24th double-double of the season.

“He’s a guy that’s going to continue to attack and that’s what we need him to do to create problems at the rim to be able to find our shooters,” Mosley said about Banchero.

The showing also served as the 10th time he scored at least 30 points this season. He added five assists.

Game of runs

The Magic actually remained within striking of the Thunder throughout much of the night. Orlando only trailed by four points after one quarter and found itself down by one at the half.

After Oklahoma City opened the second quarter on a 19-5 run, Orlando outscored the Thunder 23-6 over the final 6:39 of the first half. Once the Magic went up seven in the third, the Thunder responded again with a 15-2 run to close out the third quarter and take a six-point lead entering the final 12 minutes.

Oklahoma City then used a 7-0 run late in the fourth quarter to take 10-point lead with less than 2 1/2 minutes remaining.

“We had some great looks down the stretch and they didn’t go in,” Mosley said. “OKC capitalized on those (by) getting out in transition.

“Shai made some big plays down the stretch,” he added. “That’s why he’s MVP-race leading.”

Paint points

The Thunder outscored Orlando 60-26 in the paint during their first meeting of the season.

It was another struggle for the Magic to find consistent success in the paint on Tuesday.

Although Orlando scored 10 points in the paint in the third quarter alone after just 12 in the first half, the Thunder still outscored the Magic 54-32 in that area of the court.

Rookie watch

Second-round pick Noah Penda saw seven minutes of action but was held scoreless with two rebounds and one assist.

First-round pick Jase Richardson didn’t see the floor.

Jason Beede can be reached at jbeede@orlandosentinel.com