Lindsay painted the interior and furnished it with thrifted and secondhand items.
The shelves and nooks showcase inventory from local and regional artisans, including handmade candles from WildWood Alchemy, organic skincare products from Divinely Bloomed, items from ASTRA Aromatherapy, and soaps from Luna & Co. Soapery.
A few products, including candles, are also made and sold in-house by the Caskeys.
While the front of the store carries apothecary items, crystals, stones, and loose-leaf teas, the back includes a private room for readings and a secluded area for Reiki, which is a spiritual healing practice that practitioners believe improves the flow of energy through the body.
Arcana is also home to multiple independent readers, psychics, a resident astrologer, and a Reiki practitioner, all who manage their own pricing and schedules.