Residents and commissioners debated environmental impact as new subdivisions surge east of Tampa.

LAKEWOOD RANCH, Fla. — Since Hurricane Debby inundated parts of Manatee and Sarasota counties last year, residents and local officials remain divided over how fast subdivision development should continue in one of Florida’s fastest-growing master-planned communities.

Video from last August shows certain neighborhoods in both counties dealing with massive amounts of water after the storm moved along Florida’s Gulf Coast. The flooding revived long-standing environmental concerns about the rapid expansion of subdivisions in Lakewood Ranch. A topic that drew sharp debate during Thursday’s Manatee County Board of Commissioners meeting.

There are more than 30 distinctive villages in Lakewood Ranch, according to the county’s office of tourism.

Construction activity has surged along State Road 64, a major corridor for new communities such as Palm Grove, Savanna and Mallory Park.

That growth was front and center at the commission meeting this week.

“It’s short-sighted to keep building home after home after home and then say let’s not build anymore until we figure things out and leave everybody in homes in the middle of nowhere in bedroom communities without services, employment,” Commissioner George Kruse said.

After last year’s extreme flooding, some residents have questioned whether continued development will intensify future storm impacts. Yet, Kruse pushed back on claims that recently approved projects played a role.

“Let’s remember something, I only have one picture of a flood and it’s from June 2020. You know what wasn’t approved in June 2020? Literally any of the developments you just listed,” Kruse said.

Frustrations rose during the meeting regarding commissioners representing other districts who may not bear the consequences of their decisions.

“We care what real people who live in the real world, with real places who are affected by the decisions that you make that you’re not going to be affected by in District 2. You’re not going to be affected by in District 3 but it’s my district,” Commissioner Carol Ann Felts from District 1 said.

As the region looks toward 2026, the pace of construction shows little sign of slowing.