There are a reported five children between her and the two ex-husbands.
BRADENTON, Fla. — A Citrus County woman was charged with murder for shooting and killing her two ex-husbands at their homes in Bradenton and Tampa, according to Manatee County deputies.
The Manatee County Sheriff’s Office responded around 3 p.m. Wednesday to a home on Chatum Light Run in Bradenton, where deputies said they found a 54-year-old man suffering from two gunshot wounds.
Sheriff Rick Wells explained during a news conference that the man’s ex-wife, 51-year-old Susan Avalon, approached the door with food from Panera Bread before she started firing a gun as soon as the door opened.
Wells said the former couple had been divorced for about 10 years and had issues with custody and child support, for which she owed around $4,000 to him.
Detectives then went to the nearest Panera Bread location, where witnesses reported seeing Avalon taking food from the delivery stand that was not hers and leaving the restaurant.
Investigators used a license plate reader to track Avalon along the Sunshine Skyway Bridge and follow her back to her Citrus County home.
As authorities were outside preparing a search warrant, the sheriff said Avalon came back outside and headed to her car with bleach and cleaning rags.
MCSO then approached her and asked her questions about her ex-husband, to which she reportedly responded, “Which one?”
Avalon then made statements claiming her ex-husband was a child abuser and a molester, Wells said. She was also reportedly confusing the deputies for officials with the Hillsborough County Sheriff’s Office.
Detectives then spoke with her current boyfriend at the scene, who reportedly told them Avalon had recently discovered where her ex-husband was staying.
The boyfriend also told deputies that Avalon told him that, in case something happens, she loved him. He called it “out of character” for her, they said.
MCSO investigators then started looking into Avalon’s second ex-husband and discovered he lives in Tampa.
The Tampa Police Department then approached the second ex’s house in the area of East Frierson Avenue and initially got no answer. They reported finding damage near the rear door.
Officers then entered the home and discovered Avalon’s second ex-husband was also shot and killed earlier Wednesday morning, Sheriff Wells said.
Avalon’s current boyfriend reportedly told officials she came home following the incidents and showered with her clothes on.
Sheriff Wells said Avalon has prior cases of child abuse in 2004 in Virginia and other cases in Tampa and Pasco County. There are a reported five children between her and the two ex-husbands.
“It’s different to say the least,” Wells said. “This is bizarre.”
Avalon has been charged with murder by the Manatee County Sheriff’s Office, while the Tampa Police Department said it is working with the State Attorney’s Office to determine what charges to file.
Wells said the sheriff’s office is seeking the death penalty.