Senate Bill 1756, titled the “Medical Freedom Act,” would broaden vaccine exemptions for children. It aims to expand parental authority over children’s medical care.
JACKSONVILLE, Fla. — A bill that would expand parental authority over children’s medical care, including vaccines, is moving through the Florida Senate, drawing praise from supporters who say it strengthens family rights and warnings from medical experts who fear it could lower vaccination rates and increase outbreaks.
Senate Bill 1756, introduced last week by Republican Sen. Clay Yarborough of Jacksonville, is titled the “Medical Freedom Act.” The proposal would broaden vaccine exemptions and require additional disclosures to parents before vaccines are administered to children.
Under the bill, health care providers would be required to give parents information about vaccine risks, benefits and safety prior to vaccination. It would also expand parents’ ability to opt their children out of mandatory childhood vaccines through a conscience-based exemption, beyond current medical and religious exemptions.
Yarborough said the legislation is intended to ensure parents retain primary control over decisions affecting their child’s health.
“Parents need to be in the driver’s seat with regard to their children’s education, their well-being and their health care,” Yarborough said. “This really is about making sure that parents continue to be empowered.”
The bill acknowledges similar exemption policies in states such as Idaho and Arkansas. Yarborough said some families may object to vaccines for reasons that are philosophical rather than religious.
“There could be an individual out there who, maybe their religious belief does not compel them to not want their child to be vaccinated,” he said. “Maybe it is a matter of philosophy or conscience.”
Medical experts say informed consent is essential, but warn that broader exemptions could reduce vaccination rates and increase the risk of disease spread.
“I’m all about informing parents,” said Dr. Payal Kohli, a medical expert with First Coast News. “I don’t think you should take away information from parents.”
However, Kohli said declining vaccination rates could have serious consequences.
“When you give them a choice and they don’t quite understand the implications of choosing, not only for their child, but for the entire community, I think you’re doing a disservice from a public health perspective,” said Kohli, “You’re putting that child at risk obviously of long-term life-threatening complications, and you’re putting the rest of the community at risk as well.”
The legislation comes as measles cases are being reported across Florida. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has reported six measles cases statewide this year, and Baptist Health confirmed two pediatric cases this month.
Yarborough said his office is monitoring the situation while weighing broader policy considerations.
“Right now, I know we have some here on the First Coast, which we’re monitoring,” Yarbrough said. “My office is monitoring that too and staying on top of all of that. We’re trying to look at the big picture here and again balance, you know, parents having that right to choose for their children.”
In addition to vaccine provisions, the bill would allow pharmacists to sell ivermectin over the counter to adults without a prescription. Yarborough has said the drug helped treat people during the COVID-19 pandemic, despite repeated warnings from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration against using ivermectin for COVID-19.
The bill passed the Senate Health Policy Committee this week and must clear two additional committees before reaching the full Senate. A companion measure has been filed in the Florida House.
RELATED: Jacksonville health experts discuss the impact of Florida dropping vaccine mandates