The bill looks to protect religious expression in public schools in the state’s constitution.
TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — A debate that goes back to the nation’s founding took center stage in Tallahassee on Wednesday — church vs. state.
Florida House members passed a bill that looks to protect religious expression in public schools in the state’s constitution.
The bill seeks to place a measure on November’s ballot that, if approved by 60% of voters, would prevent schools from penalizing students who express their religious views through clothing or assignments, allow 1-2 minutes of silence each day for prayer and allow the same at high school sporting events.
“If we are not allowed to express those freedoms, they will die,” Sen. Ralph Massullo, R-Lecanto, who sponsored the companion bill in the Senate, said.
Over the last two weeks, committees in both the House and Senate have discussed and heard feedback on these companion bills, leading to lengthy debates.
Supporters of the legislation argue it’s necessary to strengthen existing law that states schools cannot discriminate against students, parents or staff for religious views.
“A lot of school districts and administrations are still confused about what the law is because of years of mixed messages that they’ve gotten,” said John Labriola with the Christian Family Coalition.
But those opposed cite the Florida statutes and the first amendment of the U.S. constitution to argue a Florida constitutional amendment isn’t necessary.
“Why do we need a constitutional amendment if this is already in statute?” Sen. Lori Berman, D-Boynton Beach, said.
Those opposed, which included Christian and Catholic Floridians, said they worry about unintended consequences of the bill — which they believe could include isolating students in a religious minority.
“I imagine that the person who is chosen to give that prayer at the championship football game comes from the dominant form of religion,” said Rev. Dr. Russell Meyer, Florida Council of Churches in front of a House committee. “I don’t imagine it being a Muslim student. I don’t imagine it being a Jewish student or a Buddhist or a Hindu.”
The bill still needs to pass the Senate, and an identical version has already moved through multiple Senate committees. It would also need to be passed by Gov. Ron DeSantis before making it on November’s ballot.