ORLANDO, Fla. (CBS12) — After a potential error at a Central Florida fertility clinic, a couple discovered their baby is not biologically theirs, and now another woman says she may be the mother.

Their attorney, Mara Hatfield, says the couple, who learned of the case from news reports, say they could be the baby girl’s biological parents, though no genetic tests have confirmed this.

Per previous reports, the couple — identified only as Tiffany Score and Steven Mills of Brevard County— underwent IVF treatment through IVF Life Inc. with Dr. Milton Mc Nichol, and entrusted the clinic with the storage of their three viable embryos.

Score gave birth to a healthy baby girl, referenced in court filings as Baby Doe, on December 11, 2025. But the couple soon noticed that the child’s appearance did not resemble either of them. Genetic testing confirmed their fear: the infant has no genetic relation.

The unnamed woman told their attorneys that, based on media photos, the couple’s baby shares her husband’s complexion. According to CBS12 partners at the South Florida Sun-Sentinel, she gave birth to a boy in December, and the implant was performed the same day as Score.

The couple reportedly wants to identify their baby’s biological parents and determine whether one of their embryos was implanted elsewhere. They allege the clinic used “ad-hoc handwritten labels” and has been slow to identify other affected patients.

Hatfield confirmed the woman’s claim by checking her public Facebook page. The unnamed woman is willing to undergo genetic testing, though none has been done yet. The filing also suggests the baby girl may have come from an embryo donated by an “Indian couple,” based on the clinic’s records.

At an emergency hearing, Score’s attorneys asked Circuit Court Judge Margaret Schreiber to require the clinic to expedite its investigation. The couple wants the clinic to identify other potentially affected patients and pay for genetic testing for children born there in the past five years.

The court ordered weekly status hearings and required the clinic to certify that patients from March 2020 to April 2025 were contacted and offered a confidentiality waiver to allow testing.

The first hearing is scheduled at 3:30 p.m. on Tuesday.