At the risk of burying the lede: This is not the world’s best pizza. It might not even be Wynwood’s best pizza, because it’s kind of hard to beat the classic cheese slice at Joe’s for $5.

This Caserta-based restaurant has not been shy about hyping itself up. The first page of the menu lists no dishes, but rather seven different awards and accolades, including “number one pizzeria in the world.” An impossibly large claim that’s just not true.

That’s not to say that this is bad pizza. There is magic in the classic margherita, which has a tender center you have no choice but to eat with a fork and knife, and a fluffy crust that weighs negative 14 ounces. It’s a great example of a classic Neapolitan-style pie that would impress even more if it didn’t ask you to expect the world of it. 

video credit: Ryan Pfeffer

interior of francesco martucciinterior of francesco martucci

photo credit: Ryan Pfeffer

video credit: Julia Malavé

Half the pizza menu has these Neapolitan-style pies, but the other half has a different style: the restaurant’s signature “pizza a due temperature,” where the dough is fried before being baked in the wood-fired oven. It’s impressive that they can subject a delicate pizza dough to so much and still make it taste decent, but it’s an unnecessary process that mainly results in a shiny, oil-soaked crust not nearly as good as the regular one.

This restaurant’s impossible-to-meet expectations are entirely self-inflicted, which is why you’ll look around the dining room, a cathedral of various shades of brown, and see table after table suspiciously poking crust, as if only here on a fact-checking mission. There really isn’t any other reason to come. The other stuff on the menu is also burdened by curveball ingredients that seem like they’ve been added just for the sake of the weirdness—like a cacio e pepe with the confusing addition of white chocolate. This place seems intent on making life more difficult than it needs to be, as evidenced by the Mission Impossible-style full-body harness system employees use to fetch wine from a glass-walled vault.

video credit: Ryan Pfeffer

You won’t find the world’s best pizza here. You’ll find good pizza, creative pizza, even interesting pizza. But Francesco Martucci is promising something a lot more exceptional than that. 

Food RundownAmuse-Bouche

Dinner here starts with this complimentary little plant. We don’t love it. Beneath that edible dirt is a cauliflower puree that needs salt.

amuse bouche from francesco martucciamuse bouche from francesco martucci

photo credit: Ryan Pfeffer

Tortelli Cacio E Pepe

These tortelli are allegedly stuffed with white chocolate, but we can’t taste it at all. That’s probably for the best, because this doesn’t need a gratuitous quirk. It’s a good pasta with a rich parmigiano reggiano cream—although size-wise it seems more like an appetizer, and it costs $38.

video credit: Julia Malavé

Margherita

A really wonderful example of classic Neapolitan pizza that’s not too overloaded with toppings. You’ve got to fork-and-knife the center, but please do lift it once you get to the crust, if only to appreciate how gravity-defying it is.

pizza from francesco martuccipizza from francesco martucci

photo credit: Ryan Pfeffer

Futuro Di Marinara

Just because you can does not mean you should. That rule applies to this pizza, which is first fried, and then baked in the wood-fired oven. The frying gives the pizza more color and a stiffer crust you can eat with your hands. It’s fun for a few bites, but the thicker parts of the slice really carry the oil and taste unpleasantly heavy. A shame, because the toppings—San Marzano tomatoes, olives, anchovies, pesto, capers, and a lot of oregano—go well together.

pizza from francesco martuccipizza from francesco martucci

photo credit: Ryan Pfeffer

A5 Wagyu + Funghi Assoluti

There are a couple of pizzas on the menu that simply exist for those seeking creative ways to lose money. This $65 pie is one of them. It’s basically a standard wood-fired pizza slapped with raw slices of A5 wagyu that get blowtorched tableside. For some reason, they pair the wagyu with fried mushrooms and fried onions, probably the last thing we want to consume alongside rich slices of fatty beef.

video credit: Julia Malavé

Sichuan Gelato

Skip this. You don’t taste the Sichuan pepper in the brittle gelato, which breaks apart as you drive a spoon through it. It’s also hard to eat because it’s plated like an art installation, not a dessert.

dish from francesco martuccidish from francesco martucci

photo credit: Ryan Pfeffer