FORT MYERS, Fla. (WINK)— Homeowners insurance is becoming a major issue in Florida’s race for governor, with Democratic nominee David Jolly and Republican nominee Byron Donalds proposing different approaches to lowering costs.
Jolly wants to move hurricane and wind risk out of the private insurance market and into a state-backed catastrophe fund. His campaign says doing so could reduce homeowners insurance costs by 60% to 70%. Under the proposal, private companies would continue covering other losses, such as fire, theft and some water damage, while the state-backed fund would carry hurricane and wind risk.
Jolly’s campaign says the fund would have to reach a financially sound level and purchase reinsurance before beginning coverage. The Legislature would ultimately be involved in establishing the specific funding structure.
“What a state catastrophic fund does is it removes hurricane and wind coverage from the private market and puts it into a state sovereign wealth fund,” Jolly said.
Jolly argues that removing hurricane exposure from private insurers would substantially reduce the amount homeowners pay those companies.
“If you go to your agent and say, ‘Could you price me a policy X wind?’ It drops by 60 to 70 percent,” Jolly said.
Florida law already requires residential property insurance rate filings to separate rates for hurricane coverage from rates for all other coverage. Premium notices are also required to separately identify those two portions.
WINK News reviewed one Lee County homeowner’s policy showing an annual premium of $3,093.93. Of that, $1,228 is listed as the hurricane premium, while $1,865.93 is attributed to non-hurricane coverage. That means the hurricane portion accounts for about 40% of this particular homeowner’s bill.
The example also illustrates one of the questions that remains about Jolly’s proposal.
While the plan would move that hurricane risk out of the private insurance market, it does not establish an individual replacement rate showing exactly what this particular homeowner would pay for hurricane protection under the new system.
Jolly’s campaign says homeowners would not be charged the $1,000 “hurricane tax” alleged in advertising from Donalds’ campaign. Jolly has proposed potential funding sources including changes to insurer taxation, real estate transaction fees and existing tourist-tax revenue, while leaving the final funding policy to the Legislature.
Blake Day, president of Day Adjusting & Consulting, has worked in Florida insurance claims since 2009. He previously adjusted claims for insurance companies and now represents policyholders.
Day said shifting hurricane exposure away from private carriers could reduce the risk those companies are responsible for, but he said important details would still need to be worked out.
“The state isn’t gonna have a free insurance program,” Day said. “There’s still gonna be premiums that they have to pay in.”
Day also raised questions about how claims would be handled under a state-run system, including who would adjust claims and what options homeowners would have if they disputed a decision.
Homeowners insurance is becoming a major issue in Florida’s race for governor, with Democratic nominee David Jolly and Republican nominee Byron Donalds proposing different approaches to lowering costs.
Byron Donalds is proposing a different approach.
Donalds’ campaign says his six-point “Bring Down The Bill” plan would preserve recent litigation reforms, change how the Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund and reinsurance operate, target mitigation grants toward projects that lower premiums, create a public insurer scorecard, reduce rebuilding costs and keep Citizens Property Insurance from expanding. The campaign says pairing those changes with savings already produced by recent reforms could lower premiums by 20% to 25%.
When Donalds accepted the Republican nomination for governor in August, he highlighted that proposal.
“On insurance, we will create a public scorecard on every insurance company in Florida, tracking how fast they pay claims and how often they deny them, bringing real competition, real transparency, and real accountability to drive rates down,” Donalds said during his nomination victory speech.
Donalds has since released a broader property insurance package that also calls for changes to the Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund, continuing insurance-related changes passed by lawmakers in 2022 and 2023, restructuring the My Safe Florida Home grant program and continuing efforts to reduce the number of Citizens Property Insurance policies.
The Insurer Scorecard proposal itself does not provide a specific dollar or percentage estimate for how much an individual homeowner’s premium would decrease. Donalds’ campaign describes the scorecard as one part of a broader effort to increase accountability and reduce premiums.
For Southwest Florida homeowners, the debate comes after years of rising insurance costs.
One homeowner told WINK News their premium remained relatively stable for about a decade before increasing by roughly $1,000 a year at each renewal from 2023 through 2025 about a $3,000 increase overall. Their premium did not increase again when the policy renewed in 2026.
Estero homeowner Christopher Phillips said insurance is one of several expenses weighing on families.
“It’s a huge weight on both of our shoulders,” Phillips said. “The cost of everything going up at this point has been difficult on a lot of families.”
Phillips said he wants more than promises from candidates when it comes to reducing insurance costs.
“Let’s not only just talk about it, but we need proof,” Phillips said. “Put it in writing. Make it real.”
Both proposals leave questions about exactly how much an individual homeowner would ultimately save. Jolly’s plan does not yet establish what a specific homeowner would pay for hurricane protection under the proposed state-backed structure, while Donalds’ proposals do not provide an individual dollar estimate for the premium reductions his campaign says greater competition, transparency and other changes would produce.