Law enforcement agencies giving conflicting information over what is and isn’t legal for license plate frames

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. — Controversy continues over the clarity of the Florida license plate law.

It’s a hot topic on social media, prompting the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles to issue a memo to law enforcement agencies in the state to help clarify what needs to be visible on a license plate.

The memo references a 2019 case surrounding the legality of a license plate frame and First Coast News contacted the attorney involved to get his take on the license plate frame debate.

Attorney Russell Cormican went to trial with a client who was pulled over in Broward County for — what police claim — was an illegal license plate frame. That stop lead to a drug charge.

“In that case, the frame partially covered some of the wording on the tag but the court found that’s not a sufficient basis to stop the vehicle. The problem that we have now is that there are varying interpretations of how much of the plate can be covered and in what manner,” said Cormican.

According to the memo released by the FLDHSMV, the law does not prohibit the use of plate frames as long as it doesn’t obscure the plate number and registration decal. Basically the new law was put in place to help prevent drivers from covering or altering their license plate and evade toll fees, and so plate information can be easily visible to law enforcement.

The issue is there has been conflicting information from several agencies posted to social media about which tag frames are legal. Cormican said the way the law is written leaves it up for interpretation.

“They open it up to what we call arbitrary and capricious enforcement of the law… so now we’re in a situation of [law enforcement] picking and choosing [who they want to pull over],” said Cormican. “…there are many types of license plates in the state of Florida and an abundance of these types of license plate frames that are being placed on vehicles mostly by the places selling them.”

Cormican said the legislature should take some steps to clear up and provide real clear guidance to avoid the confusion.

“They are really trying to crack down on the actual license plate covers that some are using to evade tolls… but it’s not written very well or very clear,” said Cormican.

So what should Florida drivers do?

“Probably the safest thing to do is take the frame off your plate because there’s a number of officers who think they can pull people over for plates that may be deemed legal… If you want to challenge the police and go to court like my client did, then leave it on,” said Cormican.

Cormican said it took years to fight the traffic stop in his client’s case and that means quite a bit of legal fees.