Guentzel put Tampa Bay ahead 5-4 at 6:38 of the third period when he backhanded a J.J. Moser wrist shot from the left point five-hole on Pyotr Kochetkov from the top of the crease.
Ryan McDonagh had a goal and an assist, and Brayden Point and Jack Finley scored for the Lightning (19-13-3), who were 0-2-1 in their past three games. Dominic James and Charle-Edouard D’Astous each had two assists. Andrei Vasilevskiy made 18 saves.
Andrei Svechnikov and Eric Robinson scored for the Hurricanes (22-10-3), who have lost two straight, including 4-3 in a shootout to the Florida Panthers on Friday. Kochetkov made 23 saves. Carolina failed to hold a three-goal lead for the second straight game.
Robinson gave the Hurricanes a 1-0 lead at 2:42 of the first period. Tampa Bay defenseman Darren Raddysh’s clear attempt was held at the blue line by Jordan Staal. Staal then fed a pass to Robinson in the right face-off circle, where he sent a one-timer five-hole on Vasilevskiy.
Jackson Blake pushed it to 2-0 with a power-play goal at 4:00 when he deflected a pass from Nikolaj Ehlers between his legs in front that went off Vasilevskiy’s stick and under his left arm.
Bradly Nadeau extended the lead to 3-0 on the power play at 12:27 with a wrist shot from the slot. The goal came during the second half of a four-minute man-advantage after Finley was given a double minor for high-sticking.
Nadeau was recalled from Chicago of the American Hockey League on Saturday after forward Seth Jarvis was injured during a 4-3 shootout loss at the Florida Panthers on Friday.
The Lightning scored two goals in the opening 1:20 of the second period to get back into the game.
Goncalves cut the deficit to 3-1 just 30 seconds into the period when he finished a feed from Dominic James in the low slot.
Point set up at the crease and redirected a pass from D’Astous into an open net behind Kochetkov to make it 3-2 at 1:20.
Finley tied it 3-3 on a breakaway at 16:36 when he put a rebound past Kochetkov’s left skate after his initial shot was stopped.
Svechnikov regained a 4-3 lead at 2:47 of the third period, skating in on a 2-on-1 and lifting a pass from Mark Jankowski over Vasilevskiy’s left pad.
McDonagh tied the game 4-4 at 3:13 after breaking through two defenders and beating Kochetkov to the five hole.
Guentzel scored into the empty net at 19:33 for the 6-4 final.