<\/p>\n
Destiny Alvarez and Judge Mavel Ruiz are running for judge in 11th Circuit Court Group 67.<\/p>\n
READ MORE<\/p>\n
Editorial Board\u2019s endorsements for primary elections<\/p>\n
\n Registered voters in Florida will be able to cast ballots in the Aug. 18 primary election through vote-by-mail, early voting or voting on Election Day. Voters will decide races for judges, the school board, the county commission, state Legislature, U.S. Senate, U.S. House and governor.\n <\/p>\n
\n Read the Miami Herald Editorial Board\u2019s endorsements.\n <\/p>\n
Expand All<\/p>\n
The race for 11th Circuit Court Judge Group 67 is between an incumbent judge, Mavel Ruiz, and challenger Destiny Alvarez.<\/p>\n
Our choice is Ruiz based on her experience and qualifications.<\/p>\n
Ruiz has been a judge since 2015. A former assistant public defender, she was reelected in 2020. During her time on the bench, Ruiz has worked to reduce her court docket, including holding hearings during lunch or after 5 p.m. She told the Editorial Board it\u2019s \u201cvery important\u201d that attorneys know when she tells them they are going to trial, \u201cthey believe me.\u201d<\/p>\n
Ruiz, 65, attracted attention last year when she presided over litigation involving the proposed Donald Trump presidential library in Miami. Ruiz initially blocked the transfer of land by Miami Dade College, though she later reversed her block on the land and dismissed the case. Afterward, the college board of trustees successfully sought to disqualify her<\/a> from presiding over future cases, saying she was personally biased in favor of the plaintiff, Miami historian and activist Marvin Dunn. She hugged him after one hearing.<\/p>\n It\u2019s fairly unusual for a sitting judge to attract a challenger<\/a> \u2014 38 judges were reelected this year because no one filed to run against them \u2014 but Ruiz has. Alvarez, 30, has been a lawyer since 2021. She said the Trump Library case wasn\u2019t the reason she chose to run. Her candidacy is about public service and giving voters a choice, she said.<\/p>\n She\u2019s an attorney at Goede DeBoest & Cross in Coral Gables, where she became a managing partner last October. Previously, she worked for two years at GrayRobinson and was a gubernatorial fellow at the Florida Department of Transportation. Alvarez has handled civil litigation, insurance disputes and HOA and condominium law.<\/p>\n Alvarez\u2019s enthusiasm for public service seems genuine, but she has yet to try a case in front of a judge or jury.<\/p>\n In contrast, Ruiz handled dozens of jury trials when she was an assistant public defender, and as a judge, she said she has presided over 50 to 100 jury trials across juvenile, criminal and civil divisions, plus numerous bench trials.<\/p>\n \u201cWhen I was 53 years old, I finally felt ready to become a judge,\u201d Ruiz told the Editorial Board. \u201cI had 50 jury trials at that time before I thought that I was worthy of being on the bench.\u201d<\/p>\n Ruiz is not a perfect candidate. In 2020, she was one of five judges who signed a letter supporting a child-welfare provider during a state contracting process, an action that resulted in reprimand from the Florida Supreme Court on grounds that the letter created the appearance of impropriety because it used the credibility of the court to boost a private company. Ruiz told the Board signing the letter was an \u201cabsolute mistake.\u201d<\/p>\n Also, the Florida Elections Commission has received complaints this year alleging Ruiz\u2019s campaign accepted two contributions above the legal limit totalling $1,250. The allegations are pending.<\/p>\n In the end, Ruiz\u2019s experience on the bench weighs most heavily.<\/p>\n The Miami Herald endorses MAVEL RUIZ for Miami-Dade Circuit Court Group 67.<\/p>\n BEHIND THE STORY MORE <\/a> Who decides the political endorsements? <\/p>\n