NEW YORK CITY (Gray DC) – Luigi Mangione appeared in federal court Friday as his defense team argued that evidence seized from his backpack should be suppressed in his trial for the killing of former UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson.
The suppression hearing focused on whether Mangione’s backpack was improperly seized and searched when he was arrested in Altoona, Pennsylvania, five days after he allegedly shot and killed Thompson in midtown Manhattan on December 4, 2024.
Altoona Deputy Chief of Police Nathan Snyder testified about procedures for seizing property during arrests. Prosecutors maintain the arresting officers followed protocol when handling the backpack. The defense argues Mangione’s rights were violated when his backpack was taken and searched during his arrest without a warrant.
Prosecutors are relying on evidence found in the backpack, including Mangione’s writings and the suspected murder weapon. Judge Margaret Garnett is considering whether to suppress this evidence while also weighing whether the death penalty should be applied in the case.
The suppression of evidence is also a crucial part of the defense’s case in Mangione’s state trial. A favorable ruling for Mangione could change the dynamic of his cases.
Mangione’s next court appearance is scheduled for Jan. 30 or a status hearing.
Copyright 2026 Gray DC. All rights reserved.