WATERTOWN, New York (WWNY) – A former Watertown City School Board member and community leader is charged with shoving a police officer at a local restaurant during a medical emergency.
City police arrested 60-year-old Milagros “Milly” Smith on Wednesday night. She was charged with second-degree harassment – physical contact.
She was issued a ticket to appear in city court on February 23.
Smith is well known in the community; she’s the chief physician assistant at QuikMed Urgent Care in Watertown and a former member of the city school district’s board of education.
What happened?
Two different accounts of what happened have emerged. What’s not in dispute is that a man started choking at Pete’s Restaurant in Watertown on January 17. The Heimlich maneuver and CPR were performed. He survived.
Milly Smith’s account
7 News spoke with Smith in January after the incident. She said a man started choking and patrons at the restaurant started to act, herself included. She said she performed the Heimlich maneuver and was about to change to CPR because the man turned blue.
According to Smith, first responders showed up about 10 minutes into the emergency. She identified herself to them as police tried to clear the area.
7 News reached out to Smith on Thursday, but she said her attorney, Todd Doldo, advised her against commenting.
The police department’s account
Watertown Police Department Detective Lieutenant Joseph Giaquinto said he had no information that Smith performed the Heimlich maneuver or CPR. He said Officer Sereenah George, who’s also an EMT, performed the Heimlich maneuver on the man.
According to Giaquinto, when EMTs from the fire department arrived, they took over the life-saving efforts and Officer George tried to clear the area to give them room.
He said Officer George held her arms up to push the crowd back.
Milly Smith allegedly knocked the officer’s arm out of the way and pushed past her, saying, “Here, let me swipe his mouth,” and, “I’m a doctor.”
Giaquinto said Officer George noted that finger sweeping of the mouth is no longer practiced in cases like this.
He also said Officer George was wearing a body camera at the time. He added that he had not reviewed the footage.
Smith’s arrest
According to the arrest report, Officer George and another police officer went to Smith’s home at 9:43 p.m. on Wednesday to charge her with harassment.
Giaquinto said it’s not unusual for the same officer named in the complaint to be the arresting officer.
Smith was issued a ticket to appear in city court on February 23.
Copyright 2026 WWNY. All rights reserved.