Should the New York Giants consider making a play for veteran guard Wyatt Teller now that he has confirmed he will not return to the Cleveland Browns in 2026?
Teller, a 31-year-old right guard, announced his departure in an emotional Instagram post, thanking Cleveland fans and reflecting on his seven-year tenure after being traded from Buffalo in 2019.
Advertisement
A three-time Pro Bowler (2021-2023) and two-time second-team All-Pro (2020, 2021), Teller has been a cornerstone of the Browns’ offensive line, starting 101 of 109 career games. His peak years featured elite run-blocking, earning high regard from analysts.
With the Giants’ interior line needing reinforcement—Greg Van Roten is aging and a free agent, while Jon Runyan Jr. could be cut—Teller offers immediate experience and power. A key connection exists: New Giants OL coach Mike Bloomgren coached Teller in Cleveland during the 2025 season, potentially easing integration into the revamped scheme under John Harbaugh.
However, red flags persist. Teller’s Pro Football Focus grades have declined sharply (from 92.2 in 2020 to 62.3 in 2025), coinciding with missed time from recurring calf injuries (eight games over the last two seasons) and past reports of attitude concerns. At his age and given the physical wear and tear of the position, a multi-year deal carries risk.
Still, on a reasonable contract—market value around $10 million annually—Teller could provide a significant upgrade and fresh start. The Giants must weigh his upside against the concerns to bolster protection for their quarterback.
This article originally appeared on Giants Wire: Should New York Giants make a play for veteran guard Wyatt Teller?