North Street.JPG

North Street, looking east, is a street divided, with homes on the right under the jurisdiction of the city of Green Lake, while homes on the left are with the town of Brooklyn. A few homes on the left side have been annexed by the city of Green Lake. 

Roger Mathews photo

The possibility of annexing several streets from the town of Brooklyn into the city of Green Lake surfaced for discussion Wednesday, Feb. 4 as the Ad Hoc Committee for Cooperative Boundary Feasibility Study began taking a closer look at roads that straddle the municipal boundary.

This comes as the committee is still finding its way on what to discuss and what goals it will pursue. Co-chairperson Thomas Penfield recently emailed the Commonwealth about the committee’s goals.

“We’ve had a number of meetings in which we’ve been getting to know one another and determining what direction we want this committee to go,” he said. “While we haven’t come up with any concrete results yet, I believe there has been an honest exchange of ideas and a realization that this is going to be a long-term project. The town of Brooklyn and the city of Green Lake do have a number of shared concerns that need to be sorted out to ensure a prosperous future for both parties.”

The meeting kicked off with Green Lake Public Works Director Jason Carley describing his findings on several streets that straddle the boundary between the two municipalities, such as North Street, between South Lawson Street and Highway 23.

While requests for annexation along North Street have been nearly nonexistent for the last few years, Carley noted that usually when a resident’s septic system begins to fail is when they start to consider annexation and connection to Green Lake’s water system.

Those utility pipes run under the street, servicing city of Green Lake residents along the south side of the street, while the other side of the street (town of Brooklyn) is served by wells and septic systems.

“What we have found is that when a resident’s septic system starts to fail, that is when the owner is looking to annex and connect to Green Lake’s system,” Carley said.

An average septic system would cost between $15,000 and $25,000, while connecting to city systems after annexation is much less expensive, averaging between $8,000 to $10,000. Carley noted that he wasn’t sure, but when the mains were installed under the street, it may have had lines for future homes installed. He said he would have to check his records.

“In most cases, once a resident is asking about annexing, they have already decided to do it,” he said.

Another drawback about annexation is that the resident then would be subject to Green Lake property taxes, which are higher than the town of Brooklyn’s rates. A check by City Clerk Melissa Zamzow during the discussion revealed that the difference between two adjacent similar-sized properties was just under $500 per year.

Also, any property that is annexed would have to cap their wells, or only use it for watering the yard. It could not be used for potable (drinking) water, Carley noted.

Other streets examined during the meeting included South Street and Lake Steel Street, with similar results. Some homes or properties on the town of Brooklyn side have been annexed to Green Lake, but for the most part the line has held steady for many years, the committee found.

Future discussions about shared streets will include Illinois Avenue, North Lawson Drive, South Lawson Drive and Forest Avenue. Committee members volunteered to examine one of the streets under discussion and return their findings at the next meeting.

“I think we’ll find that the results for these streets will be much the same as the other streets we’ve looked at,” Penfield said.

The committee also discussed the similarities between the town of Brooklyn and city of Green Lake’s comprehensive plans, as well as zoning ordinances. Parts of both plans were assigned to committee members for closer study to see if changes needed to be made to bring both entities together. Penfield noted that there would be more to come on that at a later date or meeting.

Possible parks along the Puchuyan River were discussed, but since most of the land still is in private hands, no action was taken.

The next meeting of the Boundary Committee will be Wednesday, March 25 at 3:30 p.m. in the Brooklyn town hall, N5988 County Road A, across from the Green Lake County Government Center. The public may attend the meeting.