Westchester County and New York City are about to battle it out.
The date is set: Tuesday night, April 14.
Pizza, a home’s square footage, taxes, suburb vs. city, trains vs. cars? No, this battle is not about any of those.
Advertisement
It’s about a pro soccer game. In a sport that does David vs. Goliath like no other, Westchester SC, in only its second season in the USL League One division, will host big-time Major League Soccer’s New York City FC at the 3,900-capacity Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon.
1 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Fans arrive for opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. [Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News]
1 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Fans arrive for opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. [Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News]
2 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Action from opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
3 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Action from opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
4 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester SC hats lay on a table for sale during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
5 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Fans react to a missed goal during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
6 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Fans watch the action on the field during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
7 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester’s Koen Blommestijn eyes the ball during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
8 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Fans watch the action on the field during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
9 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Liam Nasciemento 8 of Vallhalla watches the game during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
10 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester’s Juan Carlos Obregon Jr fenders off a Rhode Island player during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
11 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester SC manager Dave Carton during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
12 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Fans stave off a fly ball to the stands during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
13 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Fans cheer during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
14 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester’s Koen Blommestijn, front, holds off Rhode Island’s Frank Nodarse during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
15 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester’s Conor McGlynn drives up field during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
16 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester’s Juan Carlos Obregon Jr, front, fights for control of the ball during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
17 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Fans watch the action on the field during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
18 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Action from opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
19 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Fans visit the food trucks at the half during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
20 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester Goal keeper Dan Jacomen during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
21 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Action from opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
22 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester’s Juan Carlos Obregon Jr drives down field during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
23 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Rhode Island midfielder Kevin Vang, left, fends of Westchester midfielder Conor McGylnn during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
24 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester SC forward Jonathan Bolanos scores a goal during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
25 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester SC forward Jonathan Bolanos scores a goal during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
26 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Fans have their appearal signed by Westchester SC players after the game during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
27 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester’s Ermin Mackic signs kits for fans during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
28 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester’s Juan Carlos Obregon Jr, greets fans after the game during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
29 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester players greet fans after the game during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
30 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester players greet fans and signs kits after the game during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
31 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Fans cheer for the players after the game during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
32 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Westchester players greet fans and signs kits after the game during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
33 / 33
See Westchester Soccer Club’s 2025 opening day at Memorial Field
Action from opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
What to know: When is FIFA Men’s World Cup in the U.S., Mexico and Canada?
Westchester SC, which has started its second season, will square off at 7:30 p.m. against New York City FC, which during its league season plays against the likes of World Cup-winning Argentine megastar Lionel Messi and his Inter Miami.
NYC FC has been playing home matches at Yankee Stadium and at Citi Field, but next year is slated to move into the new Etihad Park, a gleaming, 25,000-seat stadium under construction in Queens. New York City FC’s wealthy owners include in their portfolio other pro soccer teams, particularly European powerhouse Manchester City, which is locked in a late-season duel for the English Premier League title.
Advertisement
But don’t expect some exhibition match (or friendly, in soccer parlance) when things get going Tuesday. Westchester vs. New York City is the real thing, in a competition formally called the Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup. It dates to 1914, and teams from various divisions of U.S.-based professional soccer are in the mix in the tournament’s early rounds.
The winner will go on to the next round of the competition.
Westchester SC forward Jonathan Bolanos scores a goal during opening day of the Westchester SC game vs Rhode Island FC at the Stadium at Memorial Field in Mount Vernon, NY on Sunday, April 27, 2025. Rhode Island defeated FC Westchester SC 4-1. Kelly Marsh/Special to the Journal News
Ari Kwitkin-Close, Westchester SC chief revenue officer, said that during Westchester SC’s first season, it did draw crowds of 3,000. But Tuesday’s match is set to be the team’s first sellout. A sellout would be considered 3,500.
Advertisement
“Including our standing-room sections,” he said, “we are expecting some 4,000 people.”
The U.S. Open Cup is akin to England’s Football Association Cup ( FA Cup) and Spain’s Copa del Rey, where, respectively, a Liverpool might play a lower-division team and an FC Barcelona might do the same.
The idea is that maybe a team or teams that aren’t in the top division pull off a surprise or two. Maybe even go all the way.
The odds say New York City FC goes through. But sports is replete with moments that upset the applecart, even in the Big Apple (or just north of it).
Could Westchester SC defeat New York City FC?
If Westchester SC defeats New York City FC, it will have home advantage against its next opponent. And it’s conceivable the next opponent would be none other than New York City’s other Major League Soccer team, the Red Bulls.
Advertisement
First, a bit of how this nascent Westchester vs. New York City rivalry arrived.
Westchester SC journeyed to Vermont. There, it played the Vermont Green FC, a team that’s gotten its share of ink for its own set of loyal fans. With 2,000 watching in a packed stadium, the Open Cup match between them progressed to penalty kicks to decide it (penalty kicks being in the echelon of most nerve-racking things to watch in sports). Westchester pulled off the win.
Meanwhile, Westchester SC has started well in its second league season, currently fifth of 17 squads in the USL League One standings.
New York City FC is fourth in Major League Soccer’s Eastern Division.
Advertisement
The modern-day U.S. Open Cup has tended to lead in one direction: Major League Soccer teams have won the cup every year since the turn of the century.
Kwitkin-Close said a goal is for all of the fans, from the die-hards to the new ones who may be formed Tuesday night, to “have an unbelievable experience.” Parking is free at the garage that’s just feet from the stadium. Tickets are available at westchestersc.com/single-game-tickets
Still, sports history is replete with surprises, so there is room to believe.
“Anything is possible — that’s the beauty of sports,” Kwitkin-Close said.
This article originally appeared on Rockland/Westchester Journal News: Westchester, New York City will battle it out, David vs. Goliath style