Mayor Eric Adams on Tuesday vetoed the City Council’s decision to deny land use changes needed for a proposed casino spearheaded by Bally’s in The Bronx.
The mayor’s unusual move now provides a potential lifeline for the proposal to construct a $4 billion, 500,000-square-foot gaming hall at its golf course at Ferry Point Park in Throggs Neck, along with a 500-room hotel with a spa and meeting space, retail shops, a 2,000-seat event center and two parking garages with capacity for up to 4,660 vehicles.
The state is currently evaluating where to license up to three casinos in the New York City area.
The City Council has until August 11 to garner the 34 votes that it would need to override the mayor’s veto.
Two weeks ago, the New York City Council voted 28-9 to reject the Bally’s land use application, in line with opposition from local Councilmember Kristy Marmorato, who celebrated the denial at the time.
A month before that vote, Adams made a similar last-minute intervention that lowered the threshold from 34 to 26 votes needed to adopt a home-rule resolution, clearing a path for state lawmakers to pass a bill that would allow state parkland to be used for a casino — a prerequisite for Bally’s bid to proceed.
“The City Council’s decision to treat the Bronx differently than other boroughs goes against the publicly stated, in-favor positions of the Bronx borough president and other councilmembers representing working-class neighborhoods across the Bronx,” said Adams in a statement, adding that he acted to “ensure a fair and competitive process” for selecting casino sites.
In a statement released Wednesday evening, Marmorato — a Republican in the middle of the only competitive City Council race in The Bronx this November — called the mayor’s veto “nothing short of an insult to the residents of District 13.”
“Let me be perfectly clear: I stand firmly with my constituents, and no one – not even other Bronx representatives – will come into our district and force something on us that we do not want,” she said. “Our community is not for sale, and our quality of life cannot be sacrificed for the benefit of other areas.”
A spokesperson for the Council leadership, Mara Davis, lambasted the mayor.
“Despite the self-serving claims about housing and land use by Mayor Adams and his second Charter Revision Commission in less than two years, Mayor Adams has issued the first and only land use veto during his tenure for a casino applicant, not housing,” she said in a statement. “This administration’s hypocrisy and unethical conduct is well documented and has been witnessed by all New Yorkers.”
Adams’ second intervention on behalf of the Bally’s proposal comes after a plea from other Bronx lawmakers who have all but endorsed the project outright by highlighting the casino as an economic engine The Bronx needs and touting its $625 million in promised community benefits.
Those local benefits are a requirement of the casino license process. Each casino applicant must promise to spend at least $500 million on big-ticket items for the local community as part of each proposal, according to the state gaming board, like transit upgrades, housing development and park renovations.
“This was not just a casino — it was a comprehensive economic development initiative shaped through 18 months of outreach to Bronx residents, civic groups, schools, community and small business leaders, and elected officials,” wrote councilmembers Kevin Riley and Rafael Salamanca, who serves as land use chair and just lost a bid for the borough presidency, in a Daily News op-ed. “The land is currently underutilized and isolated, with no better opportunity in sight. The project would have transformed it into a job-creating, community-supporting, tax revenue-generating destination.”
In her own op-ed published in the same paper a week later, Marmorato argued Bally’s oversold its community benefits package and iced the idea of Bally’s as an economic engine by highlighting its underperformance with revenue projections.
“No, the Bronx does not ‘need’ Bally’s casino. What the Bronx needs is more senior housing, better transit access and health care facilities, more open space and parks,” wrote Marmorato.
Bally’s has employed political power brokers as lobbyists to back its casino bid, including Stanley Schlein, who serves as attorney for the Bronx Democratic Party and helped the new Yankee Stadium clear hurdles to bring it to fruition, and former State Sen. Jeff Klein.
The Trump Organization, whose affiliate formerly ran the golf course under a city franchise, stands to receive $115 million if a casino lands on the site. Adams earlier this year had federal corruption charges dismissed after President Donald Trump’s Justice Department withdrew the case against him.
Bally’s has also leveraged its nonprofit arm to try and gain community support, funding a free bus shuttle service between the golf course and Hutchinson River Parkway. And with the help of Attorney General Letitia James, Bally’s purchased the Catholic all-girls Preston High School, which was headed for closure, for $8.5 million.
Related