On October 30, 2025, at approximately 8:47 p.m., New York State Police at Homer arrested Nyraeisa Bibbs, age 27 of Syracuse, NY for the misdemeanor of Petit Larceny and Naughtica T. Fulton, age 23 of Syracuse, NY for the misdemeanor of Criminal Possession of Stolen Property in the fifth degree.  

Troopers were dispatched to Tractor Supply on State Route 13 where a vehicle with two suspects fled the area after stealing several Carhartt jackets.  Troopers were able to obtain a description of the vehicle and the suspects.   

A Trooper located the vehicle on State Route 281 when it attempted to get onto the connector to Interstate 81 but the Trooper was able to make a traffic stop. While Troopers were interviewing Bibbs and Fulton, Fulton locked the vehicle with her key fob and threw the keys inside in an effort to hinder the investigation.  Ultimately, Troopers were able to determine that Bibbs and Fulton were the suspects in the crime and the jackets were recovered from the vehicle.  

Bibbs and Fulton were arrested and issued appearance tickets to the Cortlandville Town Court on November 24, 2025.Â