Across the country and even here in blue New York, right-wing zealots and extremist groups like Moms for Liberty have been working tirelessly to rid classrooms and library shelves of certain books.

Their top targets are often books that are about race or racism, feature people of color, or include LGBTQ+ characters. But officials censor many other books – including long-taught classics – over sex, violence, death, grief, and other frequent topics of great literature.

In the 2025-2026 school year, officials banned a record 7,370 unique titles in U.S. public schools, according to PEN America. Here in New York, extremists have mounted hundreds of challenges in recent years from Long Island to the Hudson Valley to the Rochester area.

Even in cases where officials do not ban a title, today’s hostile climate spurs complaints about books and other materials. Because many school districts lack a protocol for dealing with these challenges and do not have protections in place for library aides/media specialists and teachers, even informal complaints have a lasting impact.

The Right to Read Coalition, which includes the New York Civil Liberties Union and PEN America, just released a survey of 323 school library aides/media specialists, public librarians, and public school educators across nine regions of the state. Here’s what they had to say about how the threat of book bans impacts them and the work they do – a stress that Governor Hochul could alleviate by signing the Freedom to Read Act into law.

Pressure to Self-Censor

The Right to Read survey found that 45 percent of educators or their colleagues have, since 2020, received complaints from parents about books or materials in their classrooms. Forty-nine percent of school library aides/media specialists and 55 percent of public librarians faced similar book challenges.

Without adequate protections for professionals dealing with complaints, these requests to remove titles have a chilling effect.

“I’m always afraid of buying books that could be considered controversial, especially at the elementary level…. I also overprepare for potential encounters as a sort of defense mechanism, as if I know the day is coming and I want to be ready when it does,” one school library aide/media specialist said.

Another admitted, “I have chosen not to read any book involved in any controversial activity. There are plenty of other books to choose from.”

Voicing the concerns that give rise to self-censorship, one library aide/media specialist explained, “I always worry about ending up in the news or all over social media. It gives me a great deal of anxiety and I’ve considered leaving the profession.”

Hostility Towards Marginalized Groups

Educators and librarians use their training to create educational displays of books and materials for the communities they serve, but they quickly learn which titles to set aside in order to avoid controversy – those involving race, racism, or LGBTQ+ identities. Our survey found, for example, that 75 percent of all books or other materials in libraries and classrooms that critics targeted for removal or restriction represented LGBTQ+ people.

“More common than formal requests to remove or reconsider materials are complaints that items on display are offensive and should not be prominently on view for library users,” a public librarian explained. They noted that, in recent years, patrons have also complained about displays of books by Muslim authors.

One school library aide said their school stopped promoting library offerings altogether after a “rainbow book display” drew ire.

Another librarian reported that a patron complained there were “‘too many books on display with little black girls’ on the book covers and not enough white children on the covers.”

While we tend to think of how removing books from display or circulation affects library users, especially young people, we often fail to recognize that librarians, too, feel the impact of these decisions.

As one public librarian explained, “Administration forgets that diverse staff work in libraries, in addition to our communities. The pressure to remove or not purchase as many LGBTQIA+ materials is not only harmful to our patrons, but makes libraries a hostile place to work as a marginalized employee.”

Resilience in the Face of Threats

Despite the challenges they face from complaints and requests to remove materials, educators and librarians in our survey also said they were resolved to push back against any force preventing them from doing their work.

“These restrictions fuel my decision to fight harder for centering these books, authors, stories, and materials in my classroom,” one public school educator said.

Governor Hochul can show New York’s support for the vital work of our educators and librarians by signing the Freedom to Read Act, which requires school districts to adopt clear, rigorous protocols for handling book challenges. It also protects educators and librarians who select materials that are later removed.

Diverse books change kids’ lives by helping them both feel seen and develop empathy. The professionals who curate these titles deserve nothing less than our trust, our respect, and our thanks for helping students grow.