Klein Moynihan Turco LLP are most popular:
within Government, Public Sector and Coronavirus (COVID-19) topic(s)
Last month, Chewy, Inc. (“Defendant”) was named as a
defendant in an Americans with Disabilities Act
(“ADA”) class action lawsuit filed in the United States
District Court for the Southern District of New York. Plaintiff,
who is legally blind, alleged that Defendant violated the ADA
because its website contained accessibility barriers for visually
impaired individuals. Below, we discuss how the ADA applies to
online venues and the specifics of the subject website ADA lawsuit
brought against the Defendant.
As our readers are aware, Title III of the ADA
prohibits discrimination on the basis of a disability “in the
full and equal enjoyment of the goods [and] services . . . of any
place of public accommodation.” Self-declared
“testers,” such as Plaintiff, typically browse and
evaluate websites for potential accessibility issues. Often, these
individuals have no genuine intention of visiting a company’s
physical location or engaging in a commercial transaction through
use of the website. Instead, they initiate litigation and seek
monetary and/or injunctive relief based on alleged noncompliance
with accessibility standards. With website ADA claims steadily
increasing, it is imperative that businesses proactively implement
and maintain effective digital accessibility compliance measures to
limit legal exposure.
The Chewy Website ADA Lawsuit
The Plaintiff in Wright v. Chewy, Inc.,is a visually
impaired woman who relies on a screen reader to navigate websites.
Screen readers convert digital content into
auditory output, enabling visually impaired users to access and
interact with online information. According to Plaintiff,
accessibility barriers on Defendant’s website prevented her
screen reader from accurately relaying auditory cues. As a result,
Plaintiff claims that she was unable to complete an online purchase
of products for her pet cat. Accordingly, Plaintiff asserts that
she is entitled to relief under the ADA.
Important Considerations When Facing Website Accessibility
Claims
In internet accessibility lawsuits, a plaintiff typically
suffers an injury in fact when, among other things, it is
reasonable to infer that the plaintiff intends to return to the
subject website or location. However, to be actionable, a
plaintiff’s risk of future harm must be “material”
and “sufficiently imminent and substantial.”
Plaintiffs frequently rely on generalized or conclusory
allegations of intent to return to the subject websites in an
effort to meet this standard. In many actions, these allegations
are mere boilerplate and mirror language found in numerous website
accessibility lawsuits filed by “testers” across
jurisdictions. For example, in Chewy,Plaintiff alleges
that she “accessed [the subject website] after her case
counselor identified it as the only retailer offering both products
at accessible price points, with instructional support materials
and autoship options.” Certain courts have made clear that threadbare
recitals and conclusory allegations parroting statutory language do
not allow plaintiffs to proceed beyond the pleading stage. Given
the foregoing, businesses must conduct a fact-intensive inquiry to
scrutinize every aspect of website accessibility claims for
validity.
Use Preventative Measures to Curtail Website ADA Lawsuits
Many businesses are all too familiar with receiving demand
letters alleging violations of the ADA. Often, “testers”
distribute hundreds of nearly identical letters after brief website
visits, seeking money settlements and demanding
accessibility-related remediation. If left unaddressed, these
demand letters can quickly escalate into full-blown lawsuits.
Website operators should stay informed of evolving online ADA
requirements and proactively implement digital accessibility
measures. To minimize legal exposure, it is essential to consult
with experienced attorneys. The attorneys at Klein Moynihan Turco
regularly defend lawsuits involving alleged website accessibility
barriers and related disability-based discrimination.
If you are interested in learning more about this topic or
require representation in connection with issues involving website
accessibility, please e-mail us at info@kleinmoynihan.com or call
us at (212) 246-0900.
Similar Blog Posts:
Website ADA Lawsuit Filed Against Golden State
Warriors
Domino Effect: Will SCOTUS Refusal to Hear ADA
Website Case Yield Flood of Litigation?
New ADA Website Legislation Introduced
The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.