Milkflower’s pizzas are uniquely named, setting the stage for what is to come. “I tried the Jimmy Snuka pizza which has jalapeño, tomato, mozzarella, and pineapple. It was delicious,” described a customer on Yelp. Pizzas can be customized with added ingredients like mushroom, anchovy, egg, sausage, speck, or spicy soppressata, but when a recipe comes highly recommended you may not want to change it. The compliments keep piling up, with particular love shown for the dough itself. Customers say that it’s the perfect blend of soft and chewy. One pie, The Stun Dunn, made with caramelized onion, gruyere, scallion, red onion, and mozzarella, consistently receives rave reviews.

To finish meals, a lineup of sweet treats tempt palates. Date cakes served with ginger gelato and bourbon glaze, panna cotta topped with sour cherry preserves and candied pistachios, and tiramisu are tough options to decline. “For dessert we had the basque cheesecake, chocolate budino and chocolate gelato. The Basque cheesecake was FANTASTIC,” gushed a Yelper. 

If you live nowhere near Queens, get inspired to make your own pies imitating some Milkflower pizzas — like the Marky Marc (tomato, fontina, speck, green olives, and Fresno chili), Van Dammer (Brussels sprouts, egg, and truffle oil), Chardie Sheen (Swiss chard, speck, shiitake, and young pecorino), or the Wu-tang Clam (cherrystone clams, Fresno chili, and parsley). In the meantime, you can practice in the mirror how to order pizza in NYC without looking like a tourist.