A Michelin-starred chef is betting big on Hell’s Kitchen. Sujan Sarkar, known for his elevated Indian restaurants across the US, is returning to New York, with a new multi-concept restaurant. 

Sujan SarkarChef Sujan Sarkar at his Michelin-starred restaurant Indienne in Chicago. Photo: @sujans on Instagram.

The trio of concepts will fill the bottom two stories of the Henry Hall Apartments at 515 West 38th Street, a space previously occupied by the high-end eatery Legacy Records before it closed in August.

Opened in 2018 by Chef Ryan Hardy, Legacy Records specialized in Italian-Japanese fusions like sashimi-style crudo and signature duck dishes. It shared the two-story space with sister establishments Easy Victor Café and Ada’s Place, which catered to private events. 

The restaurant took its name from Legacy Recording Studios, which was once the East Coast’s only film-scoring studio and also recorded Broadway soundtracks. The studio was forced from the space in 2008, when the building was sold for $17.57 million to a development firm. Henry Hall Apartments, standing at 30 stories tall and housing 230 units, opened in 2017.

Sarkar’s restaurant will seat 96 on its first floor across a dining room, bar and patio, according to a floorplan submitted to Manhattan Community Board 4 (MCB4)’s Business License and Permits committee. The second floor will host two concepts, seating 143 with 13 seats on the terrace and a private dining room available for year-round events. There will be three kitchens dedicated to each concept. 

Legacy RecordsSarkar will be taking over the two-story space on W38th Street previously occupied by Legacy Records. Photo: Phil O’Brien

Originally from Kolkata, India, Sarkar made his name in the global culinary scene with upscale restaurants and cocktail bars in London, Mumbai, Delhi and Dubai. In 2017, he broke into the U.S. with ROOH, a “progressive Indian restaurant” in San Francisco, and has since followed it up with eight restaurants, including Baar Baar locations in Los Angeles and NYC.

Indienne, one of Sarkar’s three Chicago establishments, won a Michelin star in 2023. Its 10-course tasting menu – offered for vegetarian, vegan, pescetarian and omnivorous palettes – applies fine-dining approaches to classic Indian dishes, starting with small bites like dhokla and pani puri, and building toward hearty favorites like chicken makhani and paneer kofta. Complementary ingredients such as sunchoke, celeriac, buckwheat and rhubarb showcase Sarkar’s European training. 

“I think we have opened up people’s minds and perceptions to what Indian food can be,” he told Global Indian about his restaurants. “I’m offering a wider variety to a wider audience and it’s a different level of offering. They are so different as experiences even to one another. The core idea is to always offer something different in a way that would spark their curiosity to know more about Indian food.”

The 2016 Times of India Chef of the Year included Indienne’s menu in his liquor license application, possibly hinting at what local diners can expect from one of the new restaurant’s three concepts. The second floor will host a fine dining concept, he told MCB4, for which he holds bold ambitions. “The plan is to get from one [Michelin] star to two stars,” he said.


Some of the fine-dining takes on classic Indian dishes featured at Indienne in Chicago. Photos supplied.

The two other concepts will be “high-end” complements to the fine dining establishment, he added. He included a menu featuring contemporary European cuisine influenced by British and French traditions in his application as well.

Sarkar’s presentation to MCB4’s BLP committee was met with enthusiasm.

“It’s going to be spectacular,” said committee member Christine Berthet about the proposed restaurant.