STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — Forget diet resolutions, and in 2026 instead resolve to get out and enjoy the delicious, multi-faceted and diverse culinary experiences that Staten Island restaurants have to offer.
To help you on that quest, we’re doing a five-day countdown of Staten Island food and dining expert Pamela Silvestri’s picks for some of the borough’s best.
>> Read the full Staten Island’s best restaurants guide from Pamela Silvestri >>
Today, day three, dig into the best diners and late night options.
Best Diners
Andrew’s Diner – 4160 Hylan Blvd., Great Kills | 718‑948‑8544 | andrewsdiner.com — Classic diner serving hearty breakfasts, burgers, and Greek food in a family-friendly atmosphere. Everything is made from scratch including bread.
Oakwood Diner – 3161 Amboy Rd., Oakwood | 718‑668‑1570 — Neighborhood staple for all-day breakfast, sandwiches, the traditional diner fare and elaborate dinner specials.
Island Coffee Shop – 407 Manor Rd., Castleton Corners | 718‑720‑5606 — A perfect New York City coffee shop serving generous portions with a staff that knows everyone’s name—or makes you feel like family from the moment you walk in.
Best Late-Night
Guac Time Mexican Grill – 961 Jewett Ave., Meiers Corners | 718‑290‑9631 | guactimeusa.com — Quick-service Tex-Mex spot with a salubrious bent serving tacos, burritos, and bowls—fresh, flavorful, and a step above the usual fast-food rivals.
Boots – 120 Bay St., St. George | 347‑466‑0167 — A new and lively spot for booze and hot dogs with a late-night crowd and casual vibe; open Thursday through Sunday nights after 8:30 p.m.
The Coupe – 379 Van Duzer St., Stapleton | 718‑269‑0668 | thecoupenyc.com — A sister spot to Boots with a broad and stylish cocktail program offering creative drinks and small plates until 4 a.m. daily.