A minute before noon a tall, broad-shouldered defendant with a bushy moustache and a curly rug of greying hair walked into room 26a on the 26th floor of the Manhattan federal courthouse. The courtroom is ruled by Judge Alvin Hellerstein, 92, a lifelong New Yorker.
“Are you, sir, Nicolás Maduro Moros?” Judge Hellerstein inquired.
“I am president of the Republic of Venezuela and I’m here, kidnapped, since January 3,” the defendant replied, in Spanish. “I was captured at my home in Caracas, Venezuela, in —”
“Here, let me interfere,” said Judge Hellerstein, cutting him off. “There will be a time and a place to go into all of this. The counsel will be able to make motions addressing the legal sufficiency of what was done.”
• Sign up for The Times’s weekly US newsletter
This was not the time to mention Delta Force commandos roping down from Night Stalker MH-60 helicopters on a moonlit night in Caracas to capture the leader of Venezuela as he tried to lock himself in a safe room with his wife, Cilia. Or their rapid removal to a warship in the Caribbean and from there, via Guantanamo, to New York. President Trump observed that kidnapping “is not a bad term for it”. But all that could come later.
“At this time, I only want to know one thing,” said Judge Hellerstein. “Are you Nicolás Maduro?”
“I’m Nicolás Maduro Moros,” the defendant replied.

Nicolás Maduro and his wife Cilia Flores in court
REUTERS/JANE ROSENBERG
Maduro wore beige slacks and a navy V-neck top over an orange T-shirt. It was prison garb but something about the way he carried himself made the shirt look almost Hawaiian. He sat at the defence table, wearing a pair of headphones for the translation, and began writing notes. His wife sat erect at the same table in more or less the same outfit, her blonde hair tied back in a bun.
“Yes, I’m Cilia Flores de Maduro,” she said, when asked. “I’m the first lady of the Republic of Venezuela.”
“The purpose today is just to ask you who you are,” the judge said.
Anyone, be they ever so famous, can attest to an experience like this when they first land in New York. Back home you might be the first lady of Venezuela. Here they just want your name and what you have done.
Judge Hellerstein is small and bald and looks like the protagonist of a late-career Woody Allen film. “Good morning all,” he said cheerily and then corrected himself to say it was the afternoon as he appeared on the bench in front of the Maduros. At least, he almost appeared.
“This is the disadvantage of being short,” he grumbled, as he arranged himself. “Modern electronic equipment hides the judge.” He introduced himself to them courteously.
“I’m a US district judge,” he said. “It’s my job in these pre-trial proceedings, and eventually trial, to assure that this is a fair trial and a fair proceeding.”
• Was it legal for US to strike Venezuela and capture Maduro?
He would begin by summarising the indictment, he said. It said Maduro “knowingly conspired with others … to manufacture and distribute controlled substances”, Hellerstein said. The others were Diosdado Cabello Rondón, minister of the interior, justice and peace, and Ramón Rodríguez Chacín, a former minister and state governor. The judge struggled over their names before moving to firmer ground, the precise laws that were allegedly violated: “Title 21, United States Code, Section 960a, Section 3238.”
Count two was conspiracy to manufacture and distribute cocaine, the judge continued, pausing to clear his throat. “In count three, Mr Maduro and Ms Flores are charged with possession of machine guns and destructive devices,” he said. “And finally, in count four, Mr Maduro and Ms Cilia Flores are charged with conspiracy to possess machine guns …”
The judge asked if Maduro wanted him to read out the entire indictment.
“I have it in my hand for the first time,” Maduro said, standing again. “I would rather read it personally.”
Judge Hellerstein advised him of his other rights. “I did not know of these rights,” Maduro replied.
A Venezuelan lawyer named Nizar El Fakih who had come to see his erstwhile leader arraigned had observed tartly, before the hearing, that neither did hundreds of thousands of Venezuelans prosecuted by his regime.
“How do you plead,” Hellerstein asked.
“I’m innocent,” Maduro replied. “I’m not guilty. I’m a decent man. I’m president of my country.”
“A plea of not guilty will be entered on behalf of Mr Maduro,” the judge said. Soon, he had entered one for Mrs Maduro too. As his wife was told her rights Maduro pressed both hands together and lent his forehead against his fingertips.

Agents with the Federal Bureau of Prisons arrive at the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn, where Maduro and his wife are being held
KENA BETANCUR/AFP/GETTY IMAGES
“I have been making notes,” he told the judge. “I would like to make a request, your honour,” he said. “I would like to ask that my notes be respected and that I be allowed to keep them.”
Last week he controlled a country. Now he just hoped to be able to keep hold of his jottings.
“I believe you are entitled to keep them,” the judge said, though apparently this would involve the co-operation of prosecutors, US marshals and his defence lawyers.
• Trump’s hardline border tsar ‘set for top role in Venezuela’
Neither Maduro nor his wife were yet prepared to make an application for bail but their attorneys mentioned health concerns: Cilia Flores, who had a bandage on her forehead and some bruising near one eye, was said to have “sustained significant injuries” including a fracture or bruising to her ribs, and required an x-ray.
Barry Pollack, his lawyer, anticipated some “voluminous and complicated legal practice”. You could almost hear him licking his lips. “Mr Maduro is the head of a sovereign state and is entitled to the privileges and immunity that go with that office,” he said, just before his client was transported back to a jail cell in Brooklyn. He promised motions “related to his military abduction”.
They will be back in court on March 17.
“I’m a prisoner of war,” Maduro said as he was shepherded out. “You will pay!” someone yelled from the gallery.
He stopped and turned to face them. “In the name of God, you will see,” he replied. “I will be free.”