STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — The Gans Mansion at 800 Victory Blvd. in Silver Lake suffered a devastating fire in 1959, destroying the building and forcing the Island’s first Reform congregation to relocate and rebuild.
Temple Israel had purchased the mansion on Nov. 20, 1950, making it the congregation’s first permanent home.
The Gans Mansion was located at 800 Victory Blvd. on Staten Island, which served as the first permanent home for Temple Israel, the Island’s first Reform Congregation, starting in 1950.(Photo Courtesy NYC Municipal Archives)
The blaze struck on May 19, 1959, gutting the historic building.
Despite the destruction, the Torah scrolls and pulpit Bible were saved from the flames. The congregation had held its first service at the mansion on June 23, 1951, and worshipped there for eight years before the fire.
Following the blaze, a 150-unit apartment building was constructed at the 800 Victory Blvd. location in 1961. Temple Israel moved forward with plans for a new permanent home at 315 Forest Ave. in Randall Manor. The new temple was dedicated on Sept. 27, 1964, where the congregation continues today.
A150-unit apartment building was constructed at the 800 Victory Blvd. location in 1961 and still stands today across from the beautiful Silver Lake Park. (Google Maps)Staten Island Advance
The Gans Mansion played a crucial role in establishing Staten Island’s Reform Jewish community in the 1950s, before its destruction forced the congregation to start anew.