The “extraordinarily low” six-month sentence handed to a trans illegal immigrant who admitted to sexually assaulting a 14-year-old boy in Manhattan sparked outrage Wednesday from a victims’ rights group and left even former prosecutors in shock.
Legal eagles were baffled by the slap-on-the-wrist plea deal the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office struck with Nicol Alexandra Contreras-Suarez, a 31-year-old transgender woman from Colombia, in the vicious 2025 assault of a 14-year-old boy in East Harlem.
“I didn’t know you could get six months on this,” said Seth Zuckerman, a former prosecutor in the Brooklyn DA’s Office and current criminal defense lawyer.
Nicol Alexandra Contreras-Suarez is a 31-year-old transgender woman from Colombia.
“It’s generally a minimum of two and a maximum of seven, so I think something must be wrong here,” he said, referring to the penalty for the charge of second-degree rape, which Contreras-Suarez pleaded guilty to on Tuesday.
“I have got clients charged in similar statutes who are not given the same opportunity to get such a favorable deal,” Zuckerman told The Post.
The convicted rapist was promised a sentence of just six months, which has already been served, a sweetheart deal even by existing statutory standards.
The light sentence also didn’t sit well with Mark Bederow, a New York City defense attorney and former prosecutor in the Manhattan DA’s office who has worked many rape cases over his career.
“Traditionally, somebody who is preying upon a child, following them into a location and raping them — that’s a terrible crime,” he said.
He called the promised six-month jail term for the sick assault “extraordinarily low,” especially as Contreras-Suarez, who has been locked up on Rikers Island since their arrest last February, will get credit for time served at their April 27 sentencing.
The light sentence also didn’t sit well with Mark Bederow, a New York City defense attorney and former prosecutor in the Manhattan DA’s office. Steven Hirsch for NY Post
Given the immigration status of the deranged perpetrator — who was also wanted in another state for other violent crimes at the time of the attack — “that’s not generally the type of client that engenders a lot of sympathy,” Bederow added.
“Normally, the minimum for this crime would be two years, unless there are circumstances found by the court, which they would put on the record, to allow a lesser sentence,” he said.
Follow live updates on Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s socialist agenda and the latest in NYC politics
“I don’t know what those were in this case, other than the fact they wanted to spare the child from testifying and the defendant was going to be deported,” he said.
“It’s just not a good look for the DA, justifying making a light sentence because the person is scheduled to be deported, because many people are not,” he said, referring to Big Apple sanctuary policies that tie local officers’ hands in cooperating with federal immigration authorities.
According to Bederow, the minimum for this type of sentence would be around two years. Steven Hirsch for NY Post
“In terms of not wanting the child to testify and be retraumatized, it’s understandable on some level. But it is certainly the optics of a very sweetheart deal for someone who committed a terrible crime.”
DA Alvin Bragg’s office said the resolution was reached in close consultation with the victim’s family, sparing the teenager from having to testify to both the grand jury and over several days at trial.
“We expect the defendant to remain detained and be deported following sentencing, due to the felony conviction,” a spokesperson for the DA’s Office said in a statement after Judge Michele Rodney accepted the plea during a Manhattan Supreme Court hearing Tuesday.
Jennifer Harrison, founder of the advocacy group Victims Rights NY and a critic of Bragg, said it sent a chilling message.
The perpetrator was also wanted in another state for other violent crimes at the time of the attack. Steven Hirsch
“Let’s not pretend this sentence reflects real justice. It doesn’t. It sends a dangerous message that even the most horrific crimes against children won’t be met with the full weight of the law,” she told The Post.
“And what message does that send beyond this case? That predators can come into New York, rape a child, destroying their lives and still expect leniency.”
The contemptible pervert, who was born male, is scheduled to be freed next month unless federal authorities are able to intervene and remove them from the country.
NYPD used this image from surveillance cameras when looking for the perp.
The US Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond to an inquiry from The Post as to what, if any, options they were pursuing to ensure Contreras-Suarez doesn’t remain free to potentially claim more victims.
Contreras-Suarez was picked up for illegally entering the US in San Ysidro, California, in March of 2023, but was allowed to proceed into the country by the Biden administration.
According to the criminal complaint, Contreras-Suarez, who was walking a white Pomeranian dog at the time, followed the victim into a bodega bathroom across from Thomas Jefferson Park on Feb. 11, 2025, before attacking and sexually assaulting him.
The boy flagged down bystanders after the attack, and Contreras-Suarez was arrested the next day and charged.
Start your day with all you need to know
Morning Report delivers the latest news, videos, photos and more.
Thanks for signing up!
They were wanted in New Jersey and Massachusetts at the time, and were the subject of an ICE detainer in those states.
Contreras-Suarez was busted in Medford, Mass., for armed robbery, prostitution and assault with a dangerous weapon — but released due to local sanctuary policies, DHS said in July.
The city Department of Correction did not immediately say whether it would be honoring the ICE detainer lodged against Contreras-Suarez, which local authorities are allowed to obey despite sanctuary laws in cases where someone is convicted of violent or serious crimes, such as rape.
Contreras-Suarez’s legal aid lawyer did not return a request for comment Wednesday.
— Additional reporting by Craig McCarthy