Snail Mail’s Lindsey Jordan has a voice that refuses to color inside the lines. It’s one of her greatest strengths as a songwriter. When she crests to the top of the word “erase” in the chorus of 2021’s “Valentine,” her voice bleeds through the syllable, like she’s forcing out an emotion that can’t be boxed into a single note. Jordan’s first two albums—2018’s Lush and 2021’s Valentine—are full of these vocal cracks and inflections. They’re the cherry on top of her cathartic, honest songwriting. You’d be hard-pressed to find a rawer and more evocative voice in contemporary indie rock.
They’re also the greatest detriment to her live performances. This past Wednesday, Jordan, who performs with a band as Snail Mail, played the Brooklyn Paramount on the Ricochet Tour. She played through the entirety of her recently released third album, alongside a dash of catalog favorites. The show was held back by her live vocals, which erred on the wrong side of the fine line between emotive, blurred delivery and missed notes.
Snail Mail at Brooklyn Paramount in Brooklyn, NY, April 15 2026, by Bobby Nicholas III
Jordan’s voice has often been beyond even her own control. After releasing Valentine in November 2021, Snail Mail planned to go on tour immediately until an ENT discovered “massive polyps” in her vocal chords. Surgery and vocal rest soon followed. She was forced to reschedule the tour and underwent months of physical therapy to relearn to speak and sing.
As a long-time fan, I’ve seen Snail Mail live on each of her album cycles dating back to the 2018 Lush tour. Following her vocal re-training, I was hopeful that Jordan’s voice would return to the stage with more assurance and control than before. But even the new Ricochet cuts—written and recorded after Jordan already grew confident with her post-surgery vocals—sounded pitchy and trepidatious live. I’m not looking for squeaky, studio-perfect replications of her music. While her vocals on record add a unique texture and graininess, they fall flat live.
Luckily, Jordan also happens to be an excellent guitarist. The best moments of the Ricochet Tour find her focused on the six-string to amplify the catharsis of her music: the careening chorus of “Valentine,” lackadaisical little guitar lines on “Heat Wave,” stabs of Exile in Guyville-worthy chords on “Hell.” The show begins with a recorded audio describing how to play a guitar chord. Lindsey Jordan needs no such lessons.
Words by Andy Steiner
Photography by Bobby Nicholas Ⅲ
Snail Mail at Brooklyn Paramount in Brooklyn, NY, April 15 2026, by Bobby Nicholas III
Order tickets for Snail Mail HERE