If you think you’ve seen everything the NYC food scene has to offer, think again. Tucked away in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, Butcher’s Burger is serving up some of the most over-the-top, mouth-watering creations we’ve ever encountered. From five-stack smash burgers to slow-cooked ribs, this spot is a certified destination for anyone with a serious appetite.
The “Romeo” Five-Stack Smash
The star of the show might just be the Romeo Five-Stack Steak Burger Smash. We’re talking five—yes, five—prime brisket and hanger steak ground beef patties. Each layer is smothered in American cheese and topped with sweet caramelized onions, lettuce, tomato, and a generous pour of their signature Butcher Sauce, all held together by a toasted potato bun. It’s a “beast of a burger” that lives up to the hype.
Burgers with a Twist
Not enough for you? Try the Hungry Man Burger, which features a double steak smash topped with fried hot dogs and served alongside cheesy sweet potato tots. Or, if you’re craving a fusion of flavors, the Italian-American Burger comes loaded with:
A side of Parmesan-packed fried mozzarella sticks
Beyond the Bun
Butcher’s Burger isn’t just about the patties. Their menu is deep, featuring slow-cooked BBQ ribs slathered in house-made duck sauce that literally fall off the bone.
For sandwich fans, the Prime Roast Beef is a must-try. It’s served on a cheese-swiped Italian roll, packed with thinly sliced prime beef, and finished with a savory au jus and even more liquid cheese sauce. And you can’t leave without trying the Philly Cheesesteak, loaded with diced ribeye, sautéed onions, cherry peppers, and mushrooms, served with hand-breaded crispy onion rings.
Visit Butcher’s Burger
You can find this hidden gem at 551 86th St, Brooklyn, NY. Whether you’re going for the five-stack challenge or a classic cheesesteak, one thing is certain: you won’t leave hungry.
Who’s ready to head to Brooklyn? Let me know if you want another deep dive into your favorite food spots!