Outside the polling site at William E. Grady CTE High School, in a residential area of Brighton Beach tucked just under the Belt Parkway, paid canvassers in Cuomo sweatshirts stood a few feet from Mamdani volunteers handing out flyers. Some voters paused to argue or take a flyer, but most brushed past.

Brighton Beach is a historically conservative neighborhood in Brooklyn, home to many older white immigrants from Russia and Ukraine and a growing South Asian and Uzbek Muslim population. It went for Donald Trump in 2024 and for Republican Curtis Sliwa in the 2021 mayoral race. This particular election district exemplifies a neighborhood in flux: In a sea of red, the district is a bluish island that Eric Adams won just by eight votes in 2021, according to CUNY’s Center for Urban Research. 

At this polling site on Election Day, Zohran Mamdani, a democratic socialist, edged out independent candidate Andrew Cuomo by just 16 votes. Behind that slim margin were the voters, canvassers, and volunteers who showed up on Election Day, each with their own reason for being there.

 

(Credit: CUNY Graduate Center)

(Credit: CUNY Graduate Center)

 

Abdul Wahid, 42, pulled up to the polls at around 1:30 p.m. in the car he usually drives for Uber. His passengers were family members he’d brought along to vote. Some relatives had been vacationing in Pakistan, but Wahid convinced them to cut their trip short so they could return in time to cast their ballots. 

“I called them, I told them, ‘We got to vote,’” he said. “It was six to seven votes. So I spent the money on the tickets to bring them back.”

Despite being a registered Democrat, Wahid said he voted for Donald Trump in the presidential election — a choice he now regrets. 

Abdul Wahid helped his family return from vacation so they could vote. (Credit: Bella Week)

Abdul Wahid helped his family return from vacation so they could vote. (Credit: Bella Week)

 

“He just does too much cruelty right now,” Wahid said. “He just finished SNAP for the poor people, he finished Medicaid.” This year, Wahid cast his ballot for Zohran Mamdani, saying the Democrat cares about New Yorkers and will make the city safer.

A little down the block, three canvassers stood in a huddle, wearing “Vote for Cuomo” sweatshirts and holding stacks of flyers. Kevin, 19, who didn’t give his last name for fear of losing future paid canvassing work, said he heard about this job through a friend who told him there would be no paperwork and no interview. 

“It was the easiest buck I made,” he said. The canvassers said they were earning $350 for a 15-hour shift. Politics isn’t something he’s passionate about, but Kevin intended to vote for Cuomo, citing the former governor’s experience. 

A second canvasser, John Perez, 22, jumped in to challenge his colleague, “Well, he was the governor during COVID, and a lot of bad things happened when he was governor,” he said. “Like, he was just burying people everywhere.”

Perez, also wearing a Cuomo hoodie, held a flyer that read: “A vote for Sliwa is a vote for Mamdani.” Despite the campaign gear, Perez said he voted for Mamdani. 

“I just want things to be affordable,” he said, adding that he took the job for the experience and because it would look good on his resume.

A third canvasser, 31, who also didn’t want to be named for fear of losing future paid canvassing work, had a different outlook. “You know who I’m voting for? This paycheck,” he said, adding that he doesn’t typically vote because “they’re all liars anyway.” 

John Perez (Left) and Kevin (Right) wait outside a polling site in Brighton Beach to hand out Cuomo flyers. They asked not to show their faces, fearing it could cost them future paid canvassing jobs. (Credit: Bella Week)

John Perez (Left) and Kevin (Right) wait outside a polling site in Brighton Beach to hand out Cuomo flyers. They asked not to show their faces, fearing it could cost them future paid canvassing jobs. (Credit: Bella Week)

 

Afshan Ali, 30, and Lara Mira, 27, handed out flyers for the Mamdani campaign nearby. It was the first time either had ever volunteered for a political candidate. Both said it would be meaningful for them to help elect New York City’s first Muslim mayor.

“After 9/11, there were so many attacks against Muslims,” Mira said. “Even though we’re American citizens, no one made us feel like this was our home.”

For her, a Mamdani win would change that. “He’s going to make it safe for every New Yorker, regardless of your religion or your nationality,” Mira said.