By Hank Russell

As Governor Kathy Hochul recently celebrated the decline in gun violence statewide, there are some statistics that show that New York, despite falling crime numbers, does not seem to be as safe as other states. This also brings up the question of whether the state’s existing criminal reform laws are compromising law enforcement’s efforts to protect our residents.

Data from the state’s Gun Involved Violence Elimination (GIVE) program showed that, during the first eight months of this year, the number of shooting incidents involving injury fell 19% to 289, compared to 356 during the same time period last year. In addition, the number of shooting victims (persons hit) saw a 16% decline from 413 to 348 and 45 people were killed by gun violence so far this year — down 29% from January to August 2025, when 63 died.

“Keeping New Yorkers safe is my top priority — and with record investments and strong partnership with law enforcement, we’ll keep driving down gun violence to record lows,” Governor Kathy Hochul said. “I remain committed to working with law enforcement and all stakeholders to ensure safer streets and communities for families throughout every corner of our state.”

Based on the most recent data from the New York State Index Crime dashboard, there were 391,353 total crimes in 2025, down from 425,334 in 2024. The number of violent crimes fell year over year from 80,399 to 75,044 with all categories — murder, rape, robbery and aggravated assault — seeing declines across the board. Additionally, there were 316,309 property crimes last year, which is less than 2024’s total of 344,935. Last year, the state saw fewer burglaries, larcenies and motor vehicle thefts.

But a recent study from WalletHub took a look at the bigger picture, ranking New York as the 20th safest state in the country. The five safest states all hailed from the New England region: Vermont, Massachusetts, Maine, New Hampshire and Connecticut. Mississippi was the least safest.

When it comes to personal and residential safety, New York was ranked 17th in the nation. This takes into account the number of crimes per capita (murder, non-negligent manslaughter, rape, assault, theft, elder abuse, hate crimes), the number of law enforcement employees — New York is fourth in the nation — as well as active firefighters and emergency medical technicians (EMTs), and the share of children who say they live in safe neighborhoods and the share of families whose children go to safe schools.

But one aspect that may have an impact on the crime rate is the bail reform legislation passed by the Democrat-led state Legislature in 2019 and signed into law by then-Governor Andrew Cuomo. This means a prosector cannot ask for — and a judge cannot impose — bail for an offender. There is currently a list of offenses on the book that are considered non-bail-eligible, such as drunk driving and drug dealing. Some Republican legislators are pushing to repeal bail reform.

Dr. James O’Keefe, associate professor of criminal justice and homeland security at St. John’s University, said the next presidential administration can help reduce crime and improve public safety by “stopping the anti-police, defund the police rhetoric we so often hear from federal elected officials; providing federal funding for community policing strategies to advance both public safety and community involvement in policing; passing meaningful and fair gun safety legislation to remove guns from communities.” He also called for “federal bipartisan collaborations with local and state governments to properly fund and create public safety strategies and partnerships,” which he said “would be extraordinarily helpful.”

O’Keefe said local and state elected officials should “listen to local police officials before they implement well-intentioned ‘police reform bills,’” collaborate with local law enforcement and “use [data]-driven analysis to intelligently test existing reform bills” to see if they really help reduce crime.

“Defund the police, reimagine the police, bail reform and closing jails are simply not serious crime reduction or public safety strategies,” he said.