Move over, New York, there’s a new heavyweight champion in America’s culinary scene. A new study commissioned by Visit Anaheim and conducted by Talker Research has revealed that Philadelphia, Pennsylvania has officially topped the list as the nation’s No. 1 foodcation destination, beating out the Big Apple itself.

The survey of 2,000 Americans explored the growing trend of “foodcations,” trips taken specifically to experience a destination’s cuisine. According to the findings, 21% of travelers have already taken a food-focused getaway, with the average respondent traveling 484 miles and spending around $910 on their most recent trip. But food lovers are willing to pay up to $1,929 if it means tasting something that’s been on their must-try list.

At the top of that list? The iconic Philly cheesesteak, a gooey, savory sandwich that’s become synonymous with the City of Brotherly Love. For many Americans, no culinary pilgrimage is complete without biting into that perfect combo of shaved beef, melted cheese, and soft hoagie roll.

New York City came in second for its world-famous New York-style pizza, while Kansas City and Missouri ranked third for their legendary BBQ. In fourth place was Chicago, Illinois, home to deep-dish pizza that’s more casserole than slice, and rounding out the top five was Central Texas, celebrated for its slow-smoked brisket and classic BBQ culture.

Interestingly, most respondents said they prefer “hole-in-the-wall” eateries (41%) over big-name restaurants (14%) when traveling, though 45% like a mix of both. 

The top “foodcations” that Americans would like to experience

NYC pizza

GBStills / Shutterstock

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; Philly cheesesteak

New York City, New York; New York-style pizza

Missouri and Kansas; Kansas City BBQ

Chicago, Illinois; deep-dish pizza

Central Texas; Texas BBQ

Memphis, Tennessee; Memphis BBQ

Alaska; King crab

Boston, Massachusetts; lobster roll (warm with butter)

Louisiana; gumbo

Southeast; biscuits and gravy

Maine; lobster roll (cold with mayonnaise)

California; In-N-Out Burger

Maryland; Chesapeake Bay crab

California; California-style pizza

New York City, New York; pastrami on rye

Chicago, Illinois; Italian beef sandwich

Oklahoma; chicken-fried steak

Arizona and New Mexico; Navajo tacos and fry bread

Napa Valley, California; wine

San Antonio, Texas; Tex-Mex