Educators are concerned about where the future of New York City schools’ long-debated gifted and talented (G&T) program stands in the mayoral election. But the top three candidates don’t agree on the issue.
Democratic nominee Zohran Mamdani is for phasing G&T out, while independent candidate former Governor Andrew Cuomo and Republican Curtis Sliwa are for expansion.
First introduced to the city’s public school system in the 1970s, the G&T application and admissions process rigorously tests “exceptional” students around the age of four. After the 1990s, the city’s G&T programs went from being controlled by individual school districts to a more centralized process with standardized tests under mayoral control.
Where a student gets accepted is also a factor for families to consider. Not all districts have G&T classrooms, and there are no citywide G&T schools in the Bronx, Staten Island, or parts of Queens and Brooklyn. Combined with the time-consuming admissions process, it’s yet another example of inequities and segregation in the system that tend to benefit white, Asian and affluent students.
Still, when the city considered dismantling the entire program in 2019 under former Mayor Bill de Blasio in the hopes of diversifying schools, many pushed back. Instead of elimination, some educators advocated for expansion of the program without a focus on standardized tests to give more Black, Hispanic, and low-income children a chance to get in.
Black and Hispanic children made up about 30% of students in G&T for the 2023-2024 school year, reported Chalkbeat. Up from 12% in 2020, which was before the standardized exam was removed.
Current Mayor Eric Adams broke with de Blasio’s plans and became a huge proponent of expanding the G&T program when he got in office. In 2022, he and former Schools Chancellor David Banks added 100 kindergarten seats and 1,000 third-grade seats to all school districts. Students would be evaluated by their teachers in pre-K and then nominated for the program. Adams concurred that expansion ensured every child had a “fair chance” to get into an accelerated program.
With Adams dropping out of the race, G&T may be back on the chopping block with whoever succeeds him.
“I will return to the previous policy,” said Mamdani in an interview with the New York Times, indicating that he’d resume de Blasio’s plans for eliminating the G&T program. “Ultimately, my administration would aim to make sure that every child receives a high-quality early education that nurtures their curiosity and learning.”
Mamdani’s education platform hinges mostly on free childcare for all children under the age of five, a free baby basket resource for new parents and guardians, and fully funded after-school programs. But he has gone on record this month saying he would phase out the G&T program while keeping the controversial Specialized High Schools Admissions Test (SHSAT) in place. Historically, the SHSAT has been criticized for excluding certain students of color from the city’s elite high schools, only admitting a handful of Black and Hispanic students annually.
With just weeks before Election Day on Nov. 4, Mamdani is still maintaining a hefty lead (46%) when it comes to polling, according to Quinnipiac University. He favors support from Democrats, Asian American voters, voters 18 to 34 years old, voters 35 to 49 years old, and voters who identify as not being part of any religious group.
Cuomo as a second runner up (33%) is gaining some steam, due largely to Adams dropping out of the race. His strongest supporters are among Jewish voters, said the polling.
The former governor is on the opposite side of the spectrum when it comes to education issues. He has been adamant about expanding G&T in every borough and building eight new specialized high schools to create more opportunities for students. Cuomo also slammed Mamdani’s “repeated flip-flopping on the SHSAT.”
“Zohran Mamdani’s latest proposal to eliminate New York City’s gifted & talented program is not just another political stunt – it’s destructive and emblematic of a deeper problem in today’s Democratic Party – the surface level appearance of a solution is sufficient,” said Cuomo in a statement.
“The Department of Education’s own survey shows that 40% of parents who left the public school system did so because they wanted more rigorous instruction,” continued Cuomo. “If there are tens of thousands of applications for limited G&T spots, parents are telling you something: They want more of it, not less. The answer isn’t to say good riddance to those families. If there are issues with how young children are selected, then fix that and expand opportunities — give more at the start of education and more on-ramps later. Don’t eliminate the program.”
Bringing up the rear in the polls is Sliwa with 15% of voter support. He has “been a proponent of the G&T programs” throughout his campaign, said his spokesperson.
His robust education platform also includes keeping mayoral control of public schools with reforms, restoring school safety ​agents under the NYPD, restoring phonics-based reading, preserving the SHSAT, hiring more therapists, ​building new vocational high schools, addressing truancy, restoring arts programs, and implementing an audit to education department spending.
Like this:
Like Loading…
Related