The family of a Washington Heights man fatally shot by a police officer during a Bronx traffic stop in 2019 is suing the NYPD and its commissioner, Jessica Tisch.
The lawsuit looks to overturn Tisch decision two months ago that overruled a judge’s recommendation to fire Lt. Jonathan Rivera.
In a departmental trial, NYPD Judge Rosemarie Maldonado found that Rivera was not justified in shooting 31-year-old Allan Feliz as he tried to flee the stop, initially made over an allegedly undone seatbelt. Maldonado sided with the Civilian Complaint Review Board, the city’s police watchdog body.
But Tisch, who had the final say, concluded that Rivera acted reasonably, fearing that Feliz would injure other officers as they struggled in the vehicle. New York Attorney General Letitia James had also determined there was not enough evidence to prove Rivera’s use of deadly force was unlawful.
“The individual petitioners deserve to live with the peace and relief they felt when they first heard about Deputy Commissioner Maldonado’s decision and to end the suffering they have endured since Commissioner Tisch issued her opinions,” the lawsuit states.
“Mr. Feliz’s mother, brother, and sister live in fear of the police. The mother of his child has lost sleep and dreads telling her son about Commissioner Tisch’s decision,” the suit continues.
Rivera was one of several officers who pulled over Feliz. During the stop, Rivera entered the vehicle, and the two men struggled until Rivera shot Feliz in the chest. Last year, Rivera testified that he feared other officers might be run over because he couldn’t see them during the struggle.
But Maldonado found the explanation inadequate and said the use of deadly force requires more than the possibility of danger.
Members of Feliz’s family were expected to discuss their lawsuit at a rally mid-day outside of police headquarters.
This is a developing story and will be updated.