When you live in a city that eats shoes for breakfast, you quickly learn what lasts—and what actually looks chic doing it. After five winters of dodging slush puddles, sprinting for cabs, and surviving subway staircases slicked with salt, I can confirm that New York City winters don’t forgive bad footwear. I learned the hard way so you don’t have to, and I found the only seven footwear options that can actually brave NYC this season.
The perfect pair needs to check three boxes: weatherproof, walkable, and worthy of your best coat. From my go-to lug soles to polished leather boots that can face blizzards (or whatever gross puddle lies in front of your apartment entryway), these are the shoes I rely on every year—from $60.
Söfft April Waterproof Booties
Nordstrom
If you thought this list was just going to be seven pairs of snow boots, you’ll be pleased with this first pick. These waterproof booties from Söfft are one of the best fashion items you can grab—whether you live in NYC or not. For anywhere that experiences snow or rain, waterproof boots that are actually stylish are key (and frankly, hard to come by). Did I mention they’re actually comfortable with great arch support, too?
Blundstone Lug Chelsea Boots
Zappos
I can confidently say that the Blundstone Lug Chelsea Boots are one of the best investments I’ve made. I grew up in Upstate New York and lived in Vermont before moving to Brooklyn, so Blundstones have always been a practical necessity in my shoe rotation. I don’t like how hot my feet get in traditional snow boots so this lightweight option is perfect for me. Durable and waterproof, the shoes are an outdoorsy person’s ideal pair and one of Brooklyn’s biggest style symbols.
Sam Edelman Paige Boots
Nordstrom
Nine times out of ten, you’ll catch me wearing my black Paige boots. While you wouldn’t want to wear these on the biggest blizzard day of the winter, they’re the ideal dressy boots for holiday dinners, date nights, and everyday outings alike. The boots are comfortable thanks to their block heel that isn’t too big. Plus, they boast an elevated shape that’s kept them in style for the three-plus years they’ve lived in my wardrobe.
Ugg Tasman Streetscape Slip-Ons
Nordstrom
For cold walks with my dog, coffee shop stops, or standing in line for a bagel, these Uggs are the cutest way to wear my favorite winter brand without worrying the elements will ruin my look. The Tasman Streetscape Slip-Ons have waterproof bottoms that cover just enough before the classic Ugg suede shows. So, you can hit the city streets in these without a worry. Plus, platforms are so in right now.
Sorel Out N About IV Classic Waterproof Boots
Nordstrom
For those who need to hop on the subway even amid the snowiest days, these Sorel boots are the perfect companion for your commute. They’re warm, completely waterproof and not too clunky. Pack them for your weekend trips upstate too: You can dredge through the snow in these and remain completely dry—I can attest.
MIA Sefi Chelsea Boots
Nordstrom
I love a chunky and clunky pair of boots, and MIA always outdoes itself in the comfort department. This discounted pair looks chic with a great pair of jeans, since it delivers decent height thanks to its subtle wedge.
Hoka Transport Gore-Tex Sneakers
Nordstrom
Everyone needs a great pair of sneakers in their shoe arsenal. Whether they’re actually for working out, or for long holiday-shopping walks, the Hoka Transport Gore-Tex sneakers are the perfect pair. Not only are they easy to slip on thanks to their elastic laces, but they’re also completely waterproof. The kicks have trail runner tread so you won’t slip, plus great arch support.
Run to score these must-have winter pairs before the season’s official start.