STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — Close to 2,500 residential homes were sold on Staten Island in 2025, according to new data from the Staten Island Board of Realtors, which recently recorded the number of closed one-family, condo and co-op properties in the borough at 2,441 — a similar sum in comparison to last year’s total of 2,411.
According to SIBOR’s stats, the average sale price hovered at $715,727 while the borough median was approximately $680,000.
The most popular selling areas in the borough, accoring to SIBOR?
Great Kills had the most sales, totaling in at 159. Eltingville was a close second with 157 units sold. Westerleigh, New Springville and Arden Heights also put up big numbers with 129, 114 and 105 properties sold respectively.
In addition, the high-end residential real estate market flourished on Staten Island in 2025 — with the top 10 highest-selling properties in the borough garnering more than $2.3 million each, according to SIBOR.
According to records, the borough’s highest-priced home, located at 176 Benedict Rd. on Todt Hill, closed at $8.5 million in September, marking the highest residential sale in Staten Island history.