Lydia Shire doesn’t yell. In a business historically built on tantrums and testosterone, the septuagenarian Boston legend is practically revolutionary for treating her kitchen staff like human beings—quietly doing what she’s always done: cooking ridiculously good food. She’s still running the show at Scampo in the Liberty Hotel (yes, the one that used to be a jail), recently took over the kitchen at Bar Enza in Cambridge, and can spot a gluten-free diner just like that from across the room. We called her up to hear her take on everything from why Barbara Lynch deserved better to her go-to order at McDonald’s.
If you weren’t a chef, what do you think you’d be?
I would be an interior decorator, or I would be a picker. You know what a picker is?
No—what’s a picker?
A picker is somebody who travels around and finds amazing items. You know, both my parents were artists, so I grew up in a home with art, and I love beautiful objects because I’m a Libra. So if I couldn’t be an interior decorator, I probably would be a picker. I would go out and find beautiful things for people.
So restaurants with big-name chefs—has the trend sort of gotten out of control?
I wouldn’t say that. I would have to say that big-name chefs in most cities, it’s because they deserve it. They worked hard to reach the level that they are. For instance, if you go to any of Michael Scelfo’s restaurants in Cambridge, you know, his food is amazing. I love his food. Doesn’t he deserve to be named as one of the top chefs in the Boston area? I think so. The same would be said about Ken Oringer, Jody Adams, or Barbara Lynch.
Speaking of Barbara Lynch, did you feel like a lot of the criticism of her smacked of sexism?
What it smacked of to me was people, you know, smelling blood, and they jump on the bandwagon and pile on. I felt that the articles in the Boston Globe and then the New York Times were just mean-spirited and looking at the opinion of one disgruntled employee. Instead of thinking for a second about how much Barbara Lynch did for Boston—how many happy dinners did she cook for countless people in Boston? How many engagements happened at No. 9 Park?
The kitchen is, by necessity, a hierarchical place. How does that work in your restaurants?
At Scampo, for instance, the executive chef is Simon Restrepo, and I am the chef-owner. He and I have worked together side-by-side for more than 36 years. You know, he can finish my sentences. I don’t think we’ve ever really had any cross words. We just really love to be with each other, work together, and create together.
That said, the personality type that’s always depicted of a celebrity chef is a Gordon Ramsay who presents himself as you know, yelling and screaming.
Well, they kinda do in Britain. I mean, Marco Pierre White can be very mercurial, and so is Gordon Ramsay. I met Gordon Ramsay around 30 years ago. I wanted to thank him and say hello to him; when he finally agreed to come out of the kitchen, he was very close to being rude, very matter-of-fact. And Jasper White and I went to Marco Pierre White’s restaurant in London, and he came out and he was rude and kind of brusque. I guess that’s the way they do it over there.
What’s the worst disaster that has ever befallen you in the kitchen?
I think when I found out that somebody close to me was stealing from me. That was not a good thing.
What’s the most significant way in which you have evolved as a chef, either personally or in your cooking?
Well, what I’m most proud of right now, at age 76, is my brain. I feel my brain is 21 years old. My body, on the other hand—I’ve had three spine operations, and I’m still having trouble with my back, so sometimes it’s difficult to walk long distances. But boy, do I love writing menus.
What do you think is the biggest problem with food today?
In general, I think people are starved for fat. You know, if you give a piece of duck to somebody—a duck breast that you rendered, but it has that nice little rim of fat on it—they’ll grab it because it tastes so good. It distresses me when I go into a supermarket and I see package after package of skinless, boneless chicken breast. I just really like to give people something they want but wouldn’t ask for.
Like butter.
Yeah, like butter.
You’re the queen of butter.
I sure am, although I will tell you this: I actually ripped out a page in a magazine, in which they asked Thomas Keller what his favorite ingredient was to cook with, and he said butter. So I’m not the only one, I will say that.

Photograph by Pat Piasecki
What is your favorite thing to cook?
If I were at home alone and really, really hungry, I would love a skirt steak. You know, I would marinate it for 15 minutes with a little soy and ginger and sesame oil, and then I would dry it off and heavily season it, and I would sear it in my black cast-iron pan. And I would keep it rare, and yes, I would put butter on it.
Is there a spice or seasoning that you find yourself using more than any others?
I love cumin. My husband, who is from Colombia, introduced me to the beauty of cumin. For instance, when I make rice, I chop up some onion and sauté it in a little oil, and I add cumin and then the rice and water—and salt, of course, and you have to have oil when you boil rice, because that’s what keeps it separate and flaky. But the flavor of jasmine rice and some cumin seeds is delicious. Try it sometime.
What are your thoughts on things like gluten-free and other culinary fads?
Well, it’s a known fact that many people want gluten-free food who do not have celiac disease. It’s preference—I’ve joked that if you look at a 40-year-old woman with blond hair, you know she’s gluten-free. And I’m not chastising anybody. But, you know, we do take all allergies extremely seriously. The manager has to be involved so the order is placed correctly in the kitchen.
What’s one thing that no one should ever bother making at home?
I mean, unless you wanna blow up a duck with your mouth, I don’t know how you would make Peking duck at home. That’s a pretty hard one. When I was doing a Peking duck for one particular menu, and we didn’t have an air pump, I literally had to make a little slit in the skin, and I had to put the duck to my mouth and blow air into it. That’s not funny. Imagine me standing around every day blowing ducks.
“We are kind in the kitchen—we don’t scream. I never point a finger, because that’s not the right way to talk to people.”
What is your silver bullet in the kitchen?
Well, I definitely will say that we are kind in the kitchen—we don’t scream. If I see something wrong—like somebody didn’t season something correctly, or they overcooked it, or whatever—I never point a finger, because that’s not the right way to talk to people. I never say that was wrong. You make it so that we’re a team and we’re gonna better the situation.
Do you think food is love?
Oh, definitely. Oh my God, can you imagine if I were a meter maid spreading misery? I mean, we work when other people are off, and that’s a beautiful thing—they come out to dine, and they’re happy. They’re at peace; they’re relaxed. We’re there with a nice smile to really make it special.
Do you have a favorite new restaurant in Boston?
Well, I’ve been to Jody’s restaurant, La Padrona, and I’ve had a great time there. I think the food is great.
If you were on death row, what would you request for your final meal?
I think a steak and spaghetti aglio e olio.
Is there anyone from history that you’d love to cook for?
Well, I met James Beard once toward the end of his life. When I say I met him, I literally said hello and that was it—I shook his hand. And then he died shortly thereafter, but I’ve read all of his books, and I just think he was such a colorful character. I love his recipes—to this day, I still make his cream biscuits, and I make a plum pudding for Christmas from his book.
What’s the best way to cook a lobster?
You don’t want to overcook it. Because when you think of it, lobster, especially the tail, it’s a muscle—it’s how they move. So if you overcook a lobster, that tail gets pretty chewy. But if you undercook it a bit—we do our lobsters for about five minutes, depending on the size—and then put them in an ice bath, it’s so tender and delicious.
Do you think that female chefs have an edge over male chefs in the kitchen?
No, I don’t. I think it’s luck of the draw. If you eat food from a great chef, it could be a woman or it could be a man.
Do you have a favorite holiday meal?
Oh, definitely—Christmas. Oh my God, are you kidding me? I pull out all the stops. I have a giant tin of caviar that I get from Browne Trading Market in Portland. I always have plum pudding—even though my children hate it.
Do you cook at home, or does cooking ever feel like a busman’s holiday for you?
Well, I’m a huge sports lover, and football is my favorite sport. When the season opens, it’s always the beginning of September. It could be the hottest day of the year because you know how hot September can be, especially early. But I have to have a roast chicken, even though the oven heats up my house. It ushers in fall and my favorite time of year, so it’s a tradition with me now—I have to have roast chicken on football Sunday.
Okay, McDonald’s or Burger King?
McDonald’s.
Why?
I don’t know—I haven’t been to Burger King that many times, but I’ve been to McDonald’s more in my lifetime. I like Big Macs; I think they’re delicious.
If you could open any style of restaurant today, what would it be?
Oh, definitely a steakhouse, because I’ve never had a steakhouse.
What do you hope you’ll be remembered for?
I would like to say that people would see me as adventurous. And also, I would love it if people would see that the way I write a menu—the actual words—I think that I write beautiful menus. But I hope that they remember me for great flavors.

Chef Lydia Shire displaying her plate of smoked partridge at Seasons Restaurant in the Bostonian Hotel. (Photo by Steve Liss/Getty Images)
By the Numbers
The Shire Files
Vital stats on Lydia Shire’s five decades in the kitchen—and counting.
4
Shire’s age when she began cooking with her father.
1,200
Amount, in dollars, that Shire had to her name when she went to London to study at Le Cordon Bleu.
0
Number of female head chefs there had been at the Bostonian Hotel before Shire took the helm.
1.2 million
Amount, in dollars, that Shire had to raise to open the first restaurant she ever owned, Biba.
1992
Year Shire won the James Beard Award for Best Chef, Northeast.
17
Number of years that Scampo, Shire’s Italian restaurant at the Liberty Hotel, has been open.
This article was first published in the print edition of the August 2025 issue with the headline: “The Queen of Butter.”