First Deputy Mayor Randy Mastro’s side gig representing the owners of Madison Square Garden in their fight against a former Knicks player was approved by the city’s Conflicts of Interest Board, but legally shouldn’t have been, a new report from the Department of Investigation found.
The March 18 advisory opinion to Mastro — who hadn’t started his government job yet and was at that point a partner in a private law firm — stated he wouldn’t violate city’s ethics laws by representing his longtime client in its fight against Charles Oakley.
The former Knicks player was ejected from a game and later banned from the arena in 2017, later suing for defamation.
The letter ruled he could continue to represent MSG under “specific and limited circumstances” — including that he would work for free.
The advisory letter concluded that he wasn’t breaking any ethics ruling, according to DOI.
The Daily News later reported that his side gig was “cleared” by COIB but the board refused to confirm whether it gave any advice to Mastro and, following its usual practice in providing advice to city employees, declined to provide the letter to reporters.
The city investigators, in an unusual criticism of the ethics board, now found that it disregarded limits on city employees taking outside jobs.
“DOI is unaware of any legal authority supporting COIB’s view and found that COIB overlooked the law’s ‘moonlighting restrictions’ in its advisory opinion issued to First Deputy Mayor Mastro,” the report states.
Although the board’s advisory opinions are confidential, DOI took the remarkable step of obtaining the Mastro opinion anyway and releasing its contents as part of an 18-page report.
Mastro isn’t under investigation and never was, since he followed the advice of COIB.
“Based on an examination of one COIB advisory opinion involving the City’s second highest ranking executive, DOI found that COIB’s interpretation of the law is inconsistent with the plain language of Chapter 68, as well as certain prior decisions of the COIB concerning the law’s moonlighting restrictions,” DOI Commissioner Jocelyn Strauber said in a statement, referring to the City Charter’s chapter on conflicts of interest rules.
Fabien Levy, a spokesperson for the mayor, reiterated in a statement that the report “makes it crystal clear that First Deputy Mayor Randy Mastro did nothing wrong.”
Mastro did not answer THE CITY’s questions about the report. An email to COIB for comment was not returned.
COIB’s failure to make its advisory opinions public also “undermines public confidence” in its determination and limits what information is shared with the city’s more than 300,000 employees, DOI concluded.
The report recommends that COIB review the advice it gave to Mastro, as well as previously issued advisory opinions to city-employed attorneys who may be moonlighting.
It also recommended COIB potentially amend the advice it gave Mastro.
Mastro joined the administration last spring as first deputy mayor after an aborted attempt to become corporation counsel. He will officially leave City Hall on Dec. 31, although he formally “resigned” earlier this month.
Related