Queen Elizabeth broke royal protocol when she invited Kate Middleton to spend Christmas with the royal family in 2006.At the time, the 24-year-old Kate was merely dating Prince William. The family has a “no ring, no bring” rule when it came to big events, such as Christmas.Kate declined Elizabeth’s invitation in a show of tradition and patience.

Some people are just worth breaking royal protocol for—and to the late Queen Elizabeth, Kate Middleton was one of those people. All the way back in 2006, when Kate was 24 years old and merely dating Prince William, Elizabeth set aside tradition and invited her to royal Christmas at Sandringham, a privilege usually reserved for spouses (according to the “no ring, no bring” rule). How did Kate respond to such a momentous invitation, you may ask? Well, she politely turned down the queen.

Princess Kate and Queen Elizabeth on June 13, 2012.

Getty Images

This was the first time Elizabeth had invited a girlfriend to Sandringham, The Daily Mail reported. “In a surprise twist, Kate politely declined the offer, opting to stick with tradition and wait until she could attend as a married woman—with the ring to prove it,” the publication wrote, adding that such a move demonstrated Kate “valued the importance of tradition and patience.”

Royal biographer Robert Lacey put it plainly in his 2020 book Battle of Brothers: William and Harry—The Inside Story of a Family in Tumult. “By 2006, the couple had been dating seriously for the best part of five years. Yet when William invited Kate to join him that year at Sandringham for the royal family’s traditional Christmas lunch, she refused,” he wrote.

Princess Kate attends royal Christmas at Sandringham on December 25, 2011.

Getty Images

He continued: “It was the first time the Queen had extended such an invitation to an unregistered ‘girlfriend,’ but Kate had her own take on that break with tradition: she would go to Sandringham on Christmas Day only when she was engaged and had a ring to prove it. The strong-willed ‘no’ from Kate showed she was willing to abide by tradition and wait until the time was right. She was not prepared to stamp over history in her rush to marry into the royal family.”

That year, Kate instead traveled to Scotland to be with her family; it was an especially important holiday, as Kate had recently lost both of her grandmothers. “Kate was incredibly saddened to lose both her grandmothers, and this will be the first time the family will have gathered since their deaths,” a friend said at the time, per The Daily Mail. “It’s a bit of a Middleton Christmas, and there’s no way Kate would not be part of it.”

Princess Kate and Prince William at royal Christmas at Sandringham on December 25, 2011.

Getty Images

The outlet reported at the time that during the traditional royal shooting party, William was “pictured glued to his phone,” presumably texting Kate. “It appeared William seemingly regretted her decision,” it wrote.

Both Kate and William’s patience was rewarded, as the couple enjoyed their first Christmas together in 2011, eight months after they tied the knot at Westminster Abbey.