STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — Forget diet resolutions, and in 2026 instead resolve to get out and enjoy the delicious, multi-faceted and diverse culinary experiences that Staten Island restaurants have to offer.
To help you on that quest, we’re doing a five-day countdown of Staten Island food and dining expert Pamela Silvestri’s picks for some of the borough’s best.
>> Read the full Staten Island’s best restaurants guide from Pamela Silvestri >>
Today, day two, dig into the best Italian restaurants.
Fiore di Mare – 227 Mansion Ave., Great Kills | (718) 227‑9771 | fioredimaresi.com — A cozy Great Kills gem blending classic and contemporary Italian fare in a welcoming, familiar atmosphere. With a menu featuring fresh seafood, signature pastas, and creative house dishes, Fiore di Mare brings a taste of Italy to Staten Island’s southern shore.
La Bottiglia – 293 Port Richmond Ave., Port Richmond | 929‑364‑0505 | labottigliarestaurant.com — Modern Italian spot with a transporting dining room, creative cocktails and solid dishes that include house-made desserts.
Bocelli (Antica Osteria Bocelli) – 1250 Hylan Blvd., Grasmere | 718‑420‑6150 | Bocelli on Instagram — Elegant Italian dining with house-made pasta, refined wine pairings, and a sophisticated atmosphere.
Brioso – 174 New Dorp Ln., New Dorp | 718‑667‑1700 | briosoristorante.com — Classic Italian dishes and pizza served in a cozy, family-friendly setting.
Trattoria Toscana – 4200 Hylan Blvd., Great Kills | 718‑605‑6009 | trattoriatoscanasi.com — Tuscan-inspired menu featuring fresh seafood, rustic pasta dishes, and warm hospitality.
Angelina’s Ristorante – 399 Ellis St., Tottenville | 718‑227‑2900 | angelinasristorante.com — Elegant waterfront dining with refined Italian cuisine and stunning views. The service here is superb.
Il Sogno – 26 Jefferson Blvd., Annadale | 718‑356‑7800 | ilsognonyc.com — Upscale Italian dining with a romantic ambiance and seasonal specials.
La Strada – 139 New Dorp Ln., New Dorp | 718‑667‑4040 | cafelastrada.com — A longtime Staten Island favorite since 1987, La Strada offers authentic Italian cuisine and exceptional service in a warm, inviting setting.
Italianissimo – 107 McClean Ave., South Beach | 718‑442‑4442 | italianissimony.com — Traditional Italian cuisine with a focus on fresh, local ingredients.
Don Cheech – 1271 Bay St., Rosebank | 718‑285‑4401 | doncheechnyc.com — Trendy Italian-American eatery blending old-school flavors with modern flair.
Basilio Inn – 6 Galesville Ct., South Beach | 718‑720‑6835 | basilioinn.com — Historic Italian restaurant dating back to 1921, offering garden-grown herbs and authentic recipes in a bucolic setting that includes a bocce court and outdoor dining spaces.
Campania Coal‑Fired Pizza – 1801 Hylan Blvd., Dongan Hills | 718-979‑8500 | campaniacoalfiredpizza.com — Specializing in authentic coal-fired Italian pizza, antipasti and fresh house-made mozzarella, plus a full bar and rooftop/patio seating.
Trattoria Oliveto – 1642 Hylan Blvd., Dongan Hills | 347-466‑5556 | olivetonyc.com — A family-owned gem steeped in Mediterranean heritage and olive oil tradition, Trattoria Oliveto offers cozy elegance and standout Italian–Southern European dishes like mushroom ravioli, grilled octopus, seafood fra diavolo, lamb chops and penne vodka.