The death of a nearly blind refugee in Buffalo, New York, days after Border Patrol agents dropped him off at a coffee shop alone, has prompted an investigation into the circumstances of his final days and drawn sharp criticism from state and local officials.<\/p>\n
Nurul Amin Shah Alam, 56, who spoke little English, had been missing since February 19, when the agents left him at the shop shortly after he was released from the Erie County jail, officials said. His body was found five days later, around 8:30 p.m. Tuesday, about four miles from the coffee shop, the Buffalo Police Department said.<\/p>\n
Dozens of people gathered at a local mosque for Shah Alam\u2019s funeral Thursday afternoon. They prayed and went to a cemetery to lay the father to rest.<\/p>\n
There are still many unanswered questions about Shah Alam\u2019s death and what led up to it.<\/p>\n
Buffalo Mayor Sean Ryan said Thursday the Erie County Medical Examiner has not yet released full findings on his cause of death, contrasting an earlier statement from a city spokesperson who said the medical examiner conducted an autopsy and determined Shah Alam\u2019s cause of death was health\u2011related. CNN has reached out to the medical examiner for information.<\/p>\n
\u201cThe Border Patrol officers had no protocol of what to do with a disabled man who doesn\u2019t speak English, who is confused and lost. And you know what they did? They dropped him at a closed coffee shop. That\u2019s why we do not cooperate with ICE, Homeland Security and Border Patrol,\u201d Ryan said.<\/p>\n
Buffalo Police said its \u201chomicide detectives are investigating the circumstances and timeframe of events leading up to his death, following his release from custody.\u201d<\/p>\n
On Wednesday<\/a>, the mayor called Shah Alam\u2019s death \u201cpreventable\u201d and insisted CBP \u201canswer for how and why this happened.\u201d<\/p>\n New York Congressman Tim Kennedy<\/a> also called for a \u201cfull and transparent investigation at the local, state, and federal levels.\u201d<\/p>\n New York Attorney General Letitia James said her office \u201cis reviewing our legal options,\u201d according to a statement.<\/p>\n The incident highlights growing concerns over the constitutional rights and treatment<\/a> of people who come in contact with federal agents, regardless of their immigration status, in the Trump administration\u2019s mass deportation efforts.<\/p>\n A year behind bars waiting for trial<\/p>\n Shah Alam, a refugee from Myanmar, had spent much of the previous year in custody awaiting trial on criminal charges that were ultimately resolved with a misdemeanor plea deal, Erie County District Attorney Michael J. Keane told CNN in a statement Thursday.<\/p>\n Shah Alam had previously worked in construction in Malaysia and came to the US with his wife and two children, searching for opportunity, Imran Fazal, who knows the family, told CNN affiliate Spectrum News Buffalo<\/a>. He could not walk without a cane, she said.<\/p>\n He had only been in the US for a few months before his arrest, the Legal Aid Bureau of Buffalo, which was representing Shah Alam, said.<\/p>\n One of his children told Reuters<\/a> the arrest was a result of a misunderstanding with police. Shah Alam had been out for a walk and was using a curtain rod as a walking stick when he got lost and wandered onto private property, his son Mohamad Faisal said. When he did not understand officers\u2019 commands to drop the rod, Shah Alam was arrested.<\/p>\n In body camera video of the incident obtained by WGRZ, Shah Alam is seen walking through a yard with what appears to be two black poles. He appears to wave the poles in the direction of the officers, before they fire stun guns, the video shows. Shah Alam is then tackled and handcuffed.<\/p>\n The two officers were injured, according to the police report. While they were taking Shah Alam into custody, the man bit one officer on the arm and the other on the hand, the report said.<\/p>\n Shah Alam was being held on two counts of assault with intent to cause injury to an officer, a count of possession of a weapon and trespassing, among other charges, before a plea deal was reached, according to a police report<\/a>.<\/p>\n At Shah Alam\u2019s arraignment on the indictment in June 2025, his bail was modified to $5,000 cash or bond, but he remained in custody as the case moved to its trial date, the district attorney\u2019s office said.<\/p>\n In early February, Shah Alam pleaded guilty to misdemeanor charges with prosecutors and defense attorneys agreeing that he would remain in custody on bail pending a sentencing hearing set for March 24, Keane said.<\/p>\n \u201cIn this matter, the reduced disposition appropriately held the defendant accountable for the crime while avoiding a penalty that would be unduly harsh and disproportionate to the offense,\u201d Keane said.<\/p>\n His family didn\u2019t know where he was dropped off<\/p>\n Even though Shah Alam was in the US legally as a refugee, according to his attorneys, \u201cdue to the uncertainty of the current immigration climate, a strategic decision was made not to post bail for fear that he would disappear into immigration custody.\u201d<\/p>\n But later, after consulting with another attorney, the Legal Aid Bureau of Buffalo said it was determined that Shah Alam\u2019s family could post his bail and he would not be deported.<\/p>\n Shah Alam was released from jail after it was posted on February 19, Keane said.<\/p>\n As Shah Alam\u2019s discharge from jail was being processed, deputies notified US Border Patrol, which had earlier placed him under an immigration detainer, the Erie County Sheriff\u2019s Office said in a statement.<\/p>\n \u201cU.S. Border Patrol arrived at the Holding Center prior to the finalization of Mr. Shah Alam\u2019s release from Erie County Sheriff\u2019s Office custody,\u201d the statement said.<\/p>\n A spokesperson for CBP said the agents later determined Shah Alam had entered the United States as a refugee on December 24, 2024, and \u201cwas not amenable to removal.\u201d<\/p>\n \u201cBorder Patrol agents offered him a courtesy ride, which he chose to accept to a coffee shop, determined to be a warm, safe location near his last known address, rather than be released directly from the Border Patrol station,\u201d the statement said. \u201cHe showed no signs of distress, mobility issues or disabilities requiring special assistance.\u201d<\/p>\n Upon learning that Shah Alam was ineligible for removal, Border Patrol agents, using a translator program, attempted to communicate with him, according to a federal law enforcement official who said that Shah Alam asked to be taken to the location where he was eventually left. He was offered an opportunity to make a phone call but declined, the official said.<\/p>\n Ryan, the mayor, criticized the series of events by Border Patrol, saying there were ways they could have contacted someone to help Shah Alam. After it was clear he could not be removed from the country, agents did not take him back to the holding center, he said. There, they could have obtained phone numbers for his son or lawyer, who had both been active visitors while he was in custody, according to Ryan.<\/p>\n \u201cThat is bad policing, but that is also bad human beings. That is an inhumane thing to do,\u201d he said.<\/p>\n According to preliminary information, Shah Alam did not have shoes on, just orange booties from the detention center, when he was dropped off by agents, Ryan said.<\/p>\n Neither his family nor their attorney was notified by federal authorities where Shah Alam was dropped off at the coffee shop and he did not read, write or use electronic devices, his son told Reuters. Additionally, his family no longer lives in the area of the coffee shop, Shah Alam\u2019s lawyers said.<\/p>\n Ryan said that \u201cfor multiple days, there was confusion\u201d about where Shah Alam was. When he wasn\u2019t at the holding center, his family thought he was at an ICE detention center in Buffalo, the mayor said. They later found out he was released, which prompted several agencies and community groups to start searching for him, Ryan said.<\/p>\n A missing person report was filed on February 22 by Shah Alam\u2019s attorney. The next day, a police report said a detective determined that Shah Alam had been in federal custody and closed the probe, but it was reopened a few hours later when the detective found out that was no longer true.<\/p>\n On February 24, law enforcement talked to Shah Alam\u2019s son who said he last saw his father at the Erie County Holding Center five days before, a police report said. From there, detectives found out Shah Alam had been dropped off the at the coffee shop and searched the surrounding neighborhood, the document shows.<\/p>\n Later that day, someone called 911 and said there was a man that appeared to not be breathing, according to the police report. The man, later identified as Shah Alam, was pronounced dead at the scene after first responders attempted life-saving measures.<\/p>\n \u201cHow in a place like the United States of America, how does something like that happen here?\u201d a family friend, Khaleda Shah, told CNN affiliate WKBW. \u201cWe don\u2019t feel safe at all. The family does not feel safe. And here, especially in the City of Buffalo, we\u2019re supposed to be in the City of Good Neighbors.\u201d<\/p>\n The family are Arakan Rohingya refugees from Myanmar, Faisal said, referring to the stateless Muslim minority from Myanmar\u2019s Rakhine state. Hundreds of thousands of Rohingya have fled the war-torn country<\/a> since late 2016 following a brutal crackdown by the military junta that the US has since declared a genocide.<\/p>\n Shah Alam only wanted to \u201ceat home-cooked food\u201d and \u201cbe united with the rest of (his) family,\u201d Faisal told Reuters.<\/p>\n Funeral services for the father were held Thursday afternoon at a mosque in Buffalo, Faisal told CNN.<\/p>\n In his statement, Keane said his office first learned about Shah Alam\u2019s release from jail on Tuesday and will move to dismiss the charges against the man when they receive his death certificate.<\/p>\n \u201cI am saddened to learn of the tragic death of Nurul Amin Shah Alam,\u201d Keane said. \u201cI recognize the desire for answers sought by his family, friends and our community as his death remains under investigation.\u201d<\/p>\n CNN\u2019s Priscilla Alvarez and Taylor Romine contributed to this report.<\/p>\n