A jury on Friday convicted a man of the brutal 1993 killing of a woman outside Buffalo, closing the latest chapter in a winding, decades-long saga, with a swift guilty verdict on all counts.<\/p>\n
The defendant, Brian Scott Lorenz, was facing his third trial<\/a> for the murder of Deborah Meindl, a 33-year-old nursing student who walked into her Tonawanda, N.Y., home on a cold February afternoon and encountered a terror.<\/p>\n Ms. Meindl was murdered in her own dining room. She was strangled, stabbed and handcuffed, and her bloodied body was discovered by her young daughter returning home from school.<\/p>\n Mr. Lorenz, 56, was originally convicted of Ms. Meindl\u2019s murder in 1994, alongside another man, James Pugh, though the two long denied any involvement in the killing. Their pleas of innocence eventually found the support of several legal advocates, defense lawyers from New York City, who lobbied for new DNA testing in the case.<\/p>\n That testing, performed in 2018, resulted in stunning findings: There was no genetic link to either Mr. Lorenz or Mr. Pugh at the crime scene. Nor was there any other physical evidence \u2014 like hair or fiber samples \u2014 or any eyewitnesses linking either man to Ms. Meindl\u2019s murder.<\/p>\n Those DNA results, and evidence violations by prosecutors, led to the dismissal of the men\u2019s convictions in 2023, though Erie County continued to pursue the prosecutions.<\/p>\n The case was a challenge: Many of the state\u2019s witnesses from 1994, who said Mr. Lorenz had bragged about the crime, had died; others told investigators they did not remember details of their initial testimony. Still other witnesses had criminal records and, the defense said, were seeking deals for themselves.<\/p>\n A second trial of Mr. Lorenz last year ended in a mistrial<\/a> after the jury deadlocked. And in December, Mr. Pugh, 63, who had been released on parole after serving more than 25 years in prison, saw his charges dropped<\/a>. But on Friday, Mr. Lorenz was again found guilty, after less than a full day of deliberation, on two counts of murder and a burglary charge.<\/p>\n The verdict, after two weeks of testimony and arguments in Buffalo, is a defining moment in a case that has perplexed and fascinated residents of Western New York and beyond.<\/p>\n And it was vindication for the Meindl family, represented in court by the victim\u2019s sister, Lynne MacGill, and Ms. Meindl\u2019s younger daughter, Lisa Payne.<\/p>\n During closing arguments on Wednesday, Ms. Payne wore a blouse that belonged to her mother and sat in the front row of the courtroom clutching a Mickey Mouse pillow that her older sister, Jessica, had used as a comfort while testifying in 1994. (Jessica Meindl, who discovered her mother\u2019s body, struggled with addiction and died in 2020, at 37.)<\/p>\n Ms. Payne also carried a small silver spoon that Jessica had used as a reminder to stay sober, and wore rings from her parents around her neck, including the wedding ring her mother had on when she was killed. As the verdict was read, Ms. Payne nodded slightly while Mr. Lorenz sat placidly, just a few feet away. He faces sentencing on July 13.<\/p>\n After the verdict, the two family members thanked the Erie County district attorney, Michael J. Keane.<\/p>\n \u201cThis outcome is not just a legal victory: It is a testament to the persistence of truth and the unwavering commitment of dedicated public servants tasked with the pursuit of justice,\u201d Mr. Keane said in a statement.<\/p>\n Mr. Lorenz\u2019s lawyers said they planned to appeal. They had spent years building a case for exoneration, citing the lack of DNA evidence connecting Mr. Lorenz to the crime and the possibility of other suspects.<\/p>\n \u201cIt\u2019s very, very scary,\u201d said Ilann M. Maazel, one of Mr. Lorenz\u2019s lawyers. \u201cI think innocence should matter. I think the truth should matter.\u201d<\/p>\n One of the initial suspects in the case was Ms. Meindl\u2019s husband, Donald Meindl, who had been having sex with a 17-year-old girl he worked with at a Taco Bell at the time of the killing. Before the murder, he had mentioned to a friend that he wanted to have his wife killed, though he later said he was joking.<\/p>\n But the defense suggested that Mr. Meindl was serious about finding someone to kill his wife, at one point playing audio of Mr. Meindl laughing with a friend \u2014 who was wearing a wire for the police \u2014 about his wife\u2019s death. Mr. Meindl died in 2023, though he attended hearings about the case in 2021 and 2022.<\/p>\n In his summation, Earl Ward, a defense attorney, emphasized the lack of hard evidence.<\/p>\n \u201cYou have to ask yourself why there was none of Scott\u2019s DNA in that house,\u201d Mr. Ward said. \u201cBecause he wasn\u2019t there.\u201d<\/p>\n Deepening the mystery, DNA from an unknown person was found on some items used in the murder, including a knife and a necktie that was used to strangle Ms. Meindl. (The authorities in Erie County say they have not done additional testing to determine who that DNA belongs to because \u201cthe genetic material is insufficient for comparison.\u201d)<\/p>\n One of the case\u2019s lead investigators in the early 1990s, David Bentley, a Tonawanda detective, also came under scrutiny for seemingly feeding details to some witnesses. Even current prosecutors called his actions sloppy and inappropriate.<\/p>\n And Mr. Bentley had a close relationship with Richard Matt, a convicted killer from the Buffalo area who rose to infamy in 2015 when he and another inmate, David Sweat, escaped from a maximum-security prison in upstate New York<\/a>. Mr. Matt was killed by a federal agent<\/a> after a three-week manhunt. Mr. Sweat was recaptured.<\/p>\n Then, during a re-investigation of the Meindl case brought on by the new DNA evidence, two Erie County prosecutors came to believe that Mr. Matt might have been involved in killing Ms. Meindl, a theory promoted by Mr. Sweat<\/a>, himself a convicted killer who remains in prison. The judge in the case, Paul B. Wojtaszek, later discredited that theory, but nonetheless set aside Mr. Lorenz\u2019s and Mr. Pugh\u2019s convictions in 2023<\/a>.<\/p>\n The dismissal of charges against Mr. Pugh in December and the lack of physical evidence seemed to lead to a shift in prosecutors\u2019 strategy in the third trial; previously, they had argued that the two men had been burglarizing the Meindl home and killed Ms. Meindl to cover their tracks.<\/p>\n This time, prosecutors offered little in the way of motive, though a suggestion toward the end of their closing arguments that Mr. Lorenz might have killed Ms. Meindl for money drew an angry protest from the defense and a rebuke from Justice Wojtaszek. After the verdict on Friday, Mr. Lorenz\u2019s lawyers suggested that those comments by the prosecutors could be part of their appeal.<\/p>\n The state\u2019s case hinged on six associates of Mr. Lorenz who said he\u2019d told them various details about the crime, and his involvement, back in the early 1990s. Several of those people have died, so their past testimony was read to the jury. Other witnesses for the prosecution had criminal records and troubled personal histories, including addiction and mental health issues.<\/p>\n The lead prosecutor in the case, Eugene T. Partridge III, conceded in his closing that \u201cit would have been great had he confessed to a busload of nuns,\u201d but argued that \u201cthose vulnerabilities is the reason the defendant chose them.\u201d<\/p>\n Mr. Partridge also defended the long pursuit of a conviction in the case, saying \u201cthere is no expiration date on justice.\u201d<\/p>\n The jury\u2019s foreperson, Cindy Musacchio, 61, a retiree living in Tonawanda, said that prosecutors\u2019 compilation of various statements attributed to Mr. Lorenz had swayed her.<\/p>\n \u201cAll the people he confessed to, all the similarities, I felt was compelling,\u201d she said, after leaving the jury room.<\/p>\n For her part, Ms. Payne said in a statement that while \u201cnothing in this world could ever justify the brutal death of my mother,\u201d the verdict \u201cshows that as flawed as our justice system is, it can still provide a little piece of comfort.\u201d<\/p>\n \u201cMay she now finally be able to rest in peace,\u201d she wrote.<\/p>\n Jonah E. Bromwich and Mark Sommer contributed reporting.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"A jury on Friday convicted a man of the brutal 1993 killing of a woman outside Buffalo, closing…\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":209036,"comment_status":"","ping_status":"","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[6],"tags":[1774,17075,9,11,10,49,51,50],"class_list":["post-209035","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","category-new-york","tag-buffalo-ny","tag-decisions-and-verdicts","tag-new-york","tag-new-york-headlines","tag-new-york-news","tag-new-york-state","tag-new-york-state-headlines","tag-new-york-state-news"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/209035","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=209035"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/209035\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/209036"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=209035"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=209035"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=209035"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}