{"id":368065,"date":"2026-10-08T18:24:11","date_gmt":"2026-10-08T18:24:11","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/368065\/"},"modified":"2026-10-08T18:24:11","modified_gmt":"2026-10-08T18:24:11","slug":"new-york-is-fining-amish-schools-over-vaccines-so-the-amish-are-asking-the-supreme-court-for-help","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/368065\/","title":{"rendered":"New York Is Fining Amish Schools Over Vaccines, So the Amish Are Asking the Supreme Court for Help"},"content":{"rendered":"<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">New York state&#8217;s Amish community has been facing heavy government fines for allowing students to attend Amish schools without proof of vaccination. Now the Amish are asking the Supreme Court to intervene.<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">From <a data-ylk=\"slk:1966;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/news.justia.com\/new-york-allowed-to-eliminate-religious-exemption-from-school-vaccination-law\/\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">1966<\/a> to 2019, unvaccinated students were allowed to attend school in New York with a medical exemption issued by a physician, or if they &#8220;hold <a data-ylk=\"slk:genuine and sincere;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/www.casemine.com\/act\/us\/5919763fadd7b05bd4de13f3\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">genuine and sincere<\/a> religious beliefs&#8221; opposed to vaccination. But in 2018 and through 2019, a <a data-ylk=\"slk:measles outbreak;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/www.cdc.gov\/mmwr\/volumes\/68\/wr\/mm6819a4.htm\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">measles outbreak<\/a>\u2014the largest in nearly 20 years\u2014spread among the state&#8217;s Orthodox Jewish communities. Through effective disease control practices, the outbreak was contained with <a data-ylk=\"slk:zero associated deaths;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/www.cdc.gov\/mmwr\/volumes\/68\/wr\/mm6840e2.htm\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">zero associated deaths<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">Rattled, officials amended the state&#8217;s legal code in June 2019 to remove all religious exemptions to school vaccine mandates. The legislator who introduced the bill, Jeffrey Dinowitz (D\u2013Bronx), <a data-ylk=\"slk:attributed;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/www.assembly.ny.gov\/Press\/files\/20190613.php?\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">attributed<\/a> the outbreak to &#8220;misinformation and irresponsible rhetoric.&#8221; But instead of scaling up information campaigns, he chose to crack down on religious freedom.<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">In 2022, the government issued <a data-ylk=\"slk:$118,000;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/firstliberty.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/09\/26-Miller-Petition.pdf\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">$118,000<\/a> in fines targeting three rural Amish schoolhouses\u2014all of which are privately run, privately funded, and exclusively attended by members of the local Amish community\u2014for failing to comply with the mandate.<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">Amongst New York&#8217;s Amish, vaccination is <a data-ylk=\"slk:generally rare;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\/articles\/PMC8857275\/#S3\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">generally rare<\/a>. &#8220;Positions vary,&#8221; says Cory Anderson, a Penn State expert on Amish health\u2014and an Amish man himself. &#8220;But there is hesitation toward integrating unfamiliar and invasive medical practices.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">A group of Amish plaintiffs responded with <a data-ylk=\"slk:Miller v. McDonald;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/law.justia.com\/cases\/federal\/appellate-courts\/ca2\/24-681\/24-681-2026-06-30.html\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">Miller v. McDonald<\/a>. Their suit argues that the 2019 expansion of New York&#8217;s vaccine mandates violates their First Amendment right to the free exercise of their religion.<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">Under precedent set by <a data-ylk=\"slk:Employment Division v. Smith;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/supreme.justia.com\/cases\/federal\/us\/494\/872\/\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">Employment Division v. Smith<\/a> (1990), a law may burden religious exercise only if meets the &#8220;rational basis&#8221; test and if it is &#8220;neutral and generally applicable.&#8221; The Amish argue that the expanded mandate is not neutral <a data-ylk=\"slk:because;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/law.justia.com\/cases\/federal\/district-courts\/new-york\/nywdce\/1:2023cv00484\/145988\/33\/\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">because<\/a> &#8220;the State targeted religious adherents by eliminating [the] long-standing religious exemption while leaving the medical exemption process in place.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">Federal courts disagreed. In 2024, the District Court for the Western District of New York <a data-ylk=\"slk:ruled;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/law.justia.com\/cases\/federal\/district-courts\/new-york\/nywdce\/1:2023cv00484\/145988\/33\/\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">ruled<\/a> that the law &#8220;is neutral on its face, neither targeting religious belief nor singling it out for particularly harsh treatment.&#8221; In 2025, the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the lower court&#8217;s ruling.<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">While courts have historically relied on Smith to measure violations of the Free Exercise Clause, the Supreme Court has recently begun to adopt a broader interpretation of the clause, expanding parental religious rights. The Supreme Court recommended that the appellate court reconsider its rejection of the Amish petitioners, in light of <a data-ylk=\"slk:Mahmoud v. Taylor;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/www.oyez.org\/cases\/2024\/24-297\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">Mahmoud v. Taylor<\/a>. In that 2025 case, the Court ruled that parents have a constitutional right to opt their children out of certain educational programs that conflict with their religious beliefs.<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">First Liberty counsel Hiram Sasser, who is co-representing the Amish plaintiffs, tells Reason that this re-evaluation was needed because &#8220;Mahmoud revived an older case, [Wisconsin v. Yoder], that specifically involved the Amish and preserving their way of life as protected by the First and Fourteenth Amendments.&#8221; In this 1972 decision, the Court <a data-ylk=\"slk:determined;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/www.oyez.org\/cases\/1971\/70-110\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">determined<\/a> that requiring all youth to attend high school unduly limited the Amish community&#8217;s free exercise of their religion.<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">The 2nd Circuit reassessed Miller in June, but it <a data-ylk=\"slk:determined;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/law.justia.com\/cases\/federal\/appellate-courts\/ca2\/24-681\/24-681-2026-06-30.html\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">determined<\/a> that Mahmoud was not applicable because the vaccine requirement &#8220;does not regulate what children are taught [and] does not require them to affirm any belief.&#8221; With June&#8217;s decision bearing down, the Amish schools are now appealing for a second time. &#8220;Only the Supreme Court can save them now,&#8221; Sasser says.<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">New York&#8217;s vaccine mandates are unusually restrictive. &#8220;Presently, <a data-ylk=\"slk:forty-five states;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/www.kff.org\/other-health\/state-and-local-policies-on-school-vaccine-requirements-overview-and-current-status\/\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">forty-five states<\/a> have legislation allowing school-age children to be exempt from mandatory vaccination laws for religious reasons,&#8221; Sasser notes.<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">There are more productive ways to manage the state&#8217;s prevailing interest in health. &#8220;For many populations, public health needs to be a resource that can educate, not a hard top-down approach,&#8221; says Anderson, the Amish health expert. In 2014, a measles outbreak in Ohio swept through Amish groups there. In response, local health authorities worked closely with the Amish community and found the group <a data-ylk=\"slk:surprisingly willing;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/www.nejm.org\/doi\/10.1056\/NEJMoa1602295?referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com%2F#sec-3\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">surprisingly willing<\/a> to cooperate, taking vaccines and isolating themselves when infected.<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">Praising that 2014 success, Anderson <a data-ylk=\"slk:writes;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/www.statnews.com\/2026\/03\/06\/religious-exemption-vaccines-amish-vaccination-hesitancy-examined\/\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">writes<\/a> in STAT, &#8220;Successful outreach requires making effort to understand how religious adherents think, acknowledging their concerns, and humbly recognizing that medical knowledge is shaped by more than mere empiricism.&#8221; The New York government has not made that effort.<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">The Supreme Court has until November 2 to decide if it will hear the case again. If it declines, the state&#8217;s regulations will prevail, and many of the Amish will leave.<\/p>\n<p class=\"mb-4 text-lg md:leading-8 break-words\">The post <a data-ylk=\"slk:New York Is Fining Amish Schools Over Vaccines, So the Amish Are Asking the Supreme Court for Help;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/reason.com\/2026\/10\/08\/new-york-is-fining-amish-schools-over-vaccines-so-the-amish-are-asking-the-supreme-court-for-help\/\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">New York Is Fining Amish Schools Over Vaccines, So the Amish Are Asking the Supreme Court for Help<\/a> appeared first on <a data-ylk=\"slk:Reason Magazine;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas;\" data-yga=\"{&quot;yLinkElement&quot;:&quot;link&quot;,&quot;yLinkElementType&quot;:&quot;article_link&quot;}\" href=\"https:\/\/reason.com\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\" target=\"_blank\">Reason Magazine<\/a>.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"New York state&#8217;s Amish community has been facing heavy government fines for allowing students to attend Amish schools&hellip;\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":368066,"comment_status":"","ping_status":"","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[6],"tags":[9,11,10],"class_list":["post-368065","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","category-new-york","tag-new-york","tag-new-york-headlines","tag-new-york-news"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/368065","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=368065"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/368065\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/368066"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=368065"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=368065"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=368065"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}