Each fish store has its own character and appeals to different demographics across Staten Island. Here are my top picks for dedicated fish markets in the borough right now. My personal favorites? Carlos Fish in Eltingville, Fisherman\u2019s Cove at the Grasmere Met, and Belfiore in Willowbrook.<\/p>\n
All markets stay open later than their usual hours on Christmas and New Year\u2019s Eve. While Costco and BJ\u2019s remain popular, I\u2019d like to spotlight our mom-and-pop shops for their personal service and, in my opinion, a better shopping experience.<\/p>\n
Here is a curated list of options for your convenience and preference.<\/p>\n
![\"Fish](\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us-ny\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/12\/LSRWD4ZHSJDMPNVRK3QAOZQKHY.jpeg\")
In early December, 2025, here’s what the prices of fish are at Carlos Fish, a standout fishmonger in the borough, (Advance\/SILive.com | Pamela Silvestri)<\/p>\n
Carlos Fish Market \u2014 3852 Richmond Ave., Eltingville | 718-967-5758 Outstanding customer service with free fish cleaning and a pristine shop that makes for a welcoming and pleasant user experience. Offers fillets, lobsters, crabs, king crab legs and some prepped items. Hours: Mon\u2013Fri 9 a.m.\u20136 p.m.; Sat 9 a.m.\u20133 p.m.; Sun closed.<\/p>\n
Fisherman\u2019s Cove at Met Foods \u2014 1177 Hylan Blvd., Grasmere | 718-720-5800 | MetFoods at Hylan <\/a>Premium selection of salmon, flounder, shrimp, clams, mussels, scallops and heat-and-serve options. Modest offerings but everything is always super fresh plus you have the market to shop as well. Delivery through Met Foods is available. Hours: Mon\u2013Fri 7 a.m.\u20137 p.m.; Sat\u2013Sun 7 a.m.\u20136 p.m.<\/p>\n Belfiore Atlantic Fishery and Produce \u2014 2500 Victory Blvd., Willowbrook | 718-477-1041 | belfioremeats.com<\/a> Locally caught fish available as fillets or prepped meals\u2014perfect for convenience. Pleasant user experience with the perk of pork store and salumeria products. Hours: Mon\u2013Sat 8 a.m.\u20136 p.m.; Sun 8 a.m.\u20132 p.m.<\/p>\n La Bella Marketplace \u2014 99 Ellis St., Tottenville | 718-967-2070 | labellamarkets.com <\/a>Italian delicacies and frozen inventory\u2014ideal for Feast of the Seven Fishes. Unique finds include sea urchin and a broad variety of whole fish. Shop at home is available. Hours: Mon\u2013Sat 8 a.m.\u20137 p.m.; Sun 8 a.m.\u20136 p.m.<\/p>\n Rossville\/Woodrow Fish Market \u2014 655 Rossville Ave., Rossville | 718-317-6947 Reliable source for fillets, salmon, sole, halibut, tuna, branzino and swordfish. Hours: Mon\u2013Sat 8 a.m.\u20136:30 p.m.; Sun 8:30 a.m.\u20135 p.m.<\/p>\n Sea Breeze at Met Foods \u2014 1795 Victory Blvd., Castleton Corners | 718-524-0800 | MetFoods\/Castleton Corners<\/a> Fresh selections plus a well-stocked condiment and canned fish section nearby, along with the rest of Met inventory. Quick service. Shop at home through Met Foods is available. Hours: Daily 9:30 a.m.\u20136 p.m.<\/p>\n Lobster House Joe\u2019s \u2014 4707 Arthur Kill Rd., Richmond Valley | 718-227-0003 | lobsterhousesi.com<\/a> Sit-down dining area makes for a good place to eat lobsters, clams and pasta. Fish orders for fresh and cooked seafood are taken for pickup. Note that Dongan Hills location has closed<\/a>. Hours: Daily 11 a.m.\u201310 p.m.; Fri\u2013Sat until 11 p.m.<\/p>\n Manuel Fish Market \u2014 1369 Forest Ave., Port Richmond | 718-301-8229 Formerly Verrazano Seafood. Busy market with a shucker on duty and a variety of whole fish, lobsters and crab. Hours: Daily 9 a.m.\u20136 p.m. | Find them on Facebook<\/p>\n Octopus Garden \u2014 15 Newark Ave., Elm Park | 718-946-1100 | octopusgardeninc.com <\/a>Specialty items like snails, blackfish, prawns, calamaretti, and octopus\u2014cooked or uncooked, tenderized or not. Hours: Mon\u2013Sat 8 a.m.\u20134 p.m.; Sun closed.<\/p>\n Sea Breeze at Food Dynasty \u2014 1071 Bay St., Rosebank | 718-981-8571 or 718-816-1100 Whole and filleted seafood, heat-and-serve dishes, and prepped salads. Hours: Daily 8:30 a.m.\u20138 p.m.<\/p>\n